General Discussion for Ranking Game

[mndy]

Did you ever do a Companions elimination game? That would be absolutely brutal.

[RandomJoke]

It indeed would be (I fear I’d make myself some enemies with that one quickly)
Not sure if we would do it as we did two Elimination Games one for female and one for male Companions.

[BSCTDrayden]

Yes please!!!

[Tian]

We did. It was brutal.

Elimination Game - Female companions

We did the male companions let’s do the female once! The list is from Wikipedia. Don’t blame me if a companion is missing or should not be here [Skärmavbild 2024-09-13 kl. 09.39.18] Add 1 to your favourite Subtract 2 from the story you don’t fancy quite as much. 20 hours between posts. [5] Susan Foreman [5] Barbara Wright [5] Vicki [5] Katarina [5] Sara Kingdom [5] Dodo Chaplet [5] Polly [5] Victoria Waterfield [5] Zoe Heriot [5] Liz Shaw [5] Jo Grant [5] Sarah Jane Smith …

Elimination Game - Male companions

I wanted to try to make an Elimination Game. I thought that it could be fun to do one and rank the male TV companions. I thought of doing one with all companions first but the list would be too long. The list is from Wikipedia. [Skärmavbild 2024-09-12 kl. 11.08.18] Add 1 to your favourite Subtract 2 from the story you don’t fancy quite as much. 20 hours between posts. [5] Ian Chesterton [5] Steven Taylor [5] Ben Jackson [5] Jamie McCrimmon [5] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart [5] Sergean…

Elimination game - Robot/Cyborg/Dog Companions

We have done favourite male companion and favorite female companion but what about the Doctors Robot/Cyborg/Dog friends? [Group 14] Add 1 to your favourite Subtract 2 from the story you don’t fancy quite as much. 20 hours between posts. [5] K9 Mark I [5] K9 Mark II [5] K9 Mark III [5] Kamelion [5] Nardole [5] Karvanista

[shauny]

We could always redo some of the Elimination Games we have done in the past. With all the new members they may end up differently.

[TrakeniteAdventuress]

I’d love to see Regeneration stories redone.
The Caves of Androzani was robbed I tell you. Robbed!

[Tian]

Yeah i think redoing some could be fun

[MrColdStream]

We should redo all the ones with Heaven Sent and make sure it wins every category!

[Tian]

I think that we all need a break from games with Heaven Sent!

[mndy]

Reading this through my fingers. Gasping and covering my mouth. Tears in my eyes.

We should do it again

[Jamie]

If it includes 6’s actual one I’m game!

[Jae]

I’m pretty sure even my own opinions on some of the earlier ones have changed so it would be fun!

[nyssaoftraken]

I’s quite enjoy a regeneration re-elimination.

Somehow it feels more low-stakes than the writers’ games! Possibly because we’re not so much comparing like with like.

[Tian]

Aren’t there like 3 if them?

[Jamie]

one boxset, 4 stories

[DarthGallifrey]

I find it interesting that the current elimination game is down to Jodie’s first story, last story, and one other.

[Tian]

There is also the book Spiral Scratch.

Spiral Scratch · BBC Books

[uss-genderprise]

If we do it again I’m downvoting it immediately. 1/5 story for me.

[TARDIS32]

It’s ok. The sensible ones of us will bring it back up.

[Tian]

I made a silly one. It will go live in a little over an hour