Or the “Doctor Doppelgänger” trope?
5 Likes
They hated him because he was right
2 Likes
Honestly I’m more surprised Woman Who Fell is still there.
3 Likes
- Fantastic story?
- Best Doctor intro out there?
- Grace?
- Best “Doctor choosing outfit scene” ever?
- “Eat my salad Halloween!”?
- Tim Shaw?
- Great monster design?
- Grace?!
- That. Jump. !. ?
- Ryan’s poor attempt at YouTubing?
- Great cliffhanger?
- Building a bloody sonic screwdriver from spoons!??
- Getting out of the “Murray Gold Rut”?
- Bloody gorgeous cinematography?
What’s there to be surprised about? 
9 Likes
Fantastic? Exposition heavy and actually not a lot happening for most of it more like.
Best Doctor intro? Unearthly, Power, Spearhead, Robot, Eleventh, and Breath would all like a word.
We all love Grace, you got me there.
I guess the outfit scene is fine, shame I don’t like the outfit.
Salad man is a treasure
Tzim Sha is pretty lame ngl, and the Tim Shaw joke went on a little long
Is he that well designed? He’s just got teeth on his face.
See above
Jump was cool
See, you said it, “poor attempt”
Cool cliffhanger, true
Best scene of the episode
I like Murray Gold, but Akinola was a nice change of pace
It is good cinematography, shame that’s not as important as writing for something to be good.
5 Likes
It should say “Doctor intro scene”. 
Power of the Daleks and Eleventh Hour are better.
We all love what we love
4 Likes
I mean, his attempts at youtubing are better than his attempts to emulate Call of Duty and his musical taste…
7 Likes
That’s still 9/14 things you agree with, so I’d call that pretty good
4 Likes
You put this as a good thing?
3 Likes
I didn’t say it was bad, I just am surprised we’re seemingly considering it top four Chibnall good, when I think it’s just ok.
4 Likes
How could I have guessed that you would say that 
7 Likes
I just think it’s a bit of fun
4 Likes
I’ve not taken part in a few days cause tbh every episode I dislike is gone, and all that remains are ones I don’t remember too well but found decent at the time, or ones I like. So voting has become hard, and voting fairly impossible due to my poor memory 
5 Likes
Don’t look at the Romana folders on my phone 
10 Likes
The way that things are said about the matter are roughly that Maxine was writing the story for Series 13… COVID came along… All the discussions about whether the show could actually happen came up… And that was the only script far enough into development that it could then be reworked for Flux. It’s hard to say without actually speaking to either of them if this was a traditional co-write situation or if the credit is the result of Maxine having done a draft or two, followed by Chris powering through drafts of rewrites thereafter on his own.
Given that all the other planned Series 13 writers weren’t then involved in Flux, I would suspect myself that Chris did all the reworking and redrafting himself on a tight turnaround - because I mean, why else is he shouldering all that writing weight upon himself?
10 Likes
Yes!!! Some more precious few seconds with him 
! Power is super messy, but they got me with the fanservice trap. Fanservice bad unless I am the fan being serviced \j
11 Likes
Power is just fun. And that’s what Doctor Who should be, at the end of the day. I don’t care how messy the story is if I’m having a good time watching it.
9 Likes
How about an Elimination Game about which Doctor deserves more onscreen Time? A very simple Game since at the end most would probably vote for two big choices, so it wouldn’t be as much as a bloodbath 
(maybe…)
Anyway, the other Ideas all do sound good! I’d be open for any of them.
As for Power, yes it’s very much messy, but it has also McGann, which makes it automatically good. As we all know, every Era of the Show should be judge in terms of how much McGann it has
7 Likes
That is fun! T Baker would go fast!
3 Likes
We did Hartnell writers, we can always do Troughton writers.
5 Likes