Elimination Game - Female companions

[Tian]

We did the male companions let’s do the female once! The list is from Wikipedia. Don’t blame me if a companion is missing or should not be here

Add 1 to your favourite
Subtract 2 from the story you don’t fancy quite as much.
20 hours between posts.

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[5] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[5] Jo Grant
[5] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[5] Romana I
[5] Romana II
[5] Nyssa
[5] Tegan Jovanka
[5] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[5] Rose Tyler
[5] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Astrid Peth
[5] Lady Christina de Souza
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[5] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[5] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

[sircarolyn]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[5] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[5] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[5] Romana I
[5] Romana II
[5] Nyssa
[5] Tegan Jovanka
[5] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[5] Rose Tyler
[5] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Astrid Peth
[3] Lady Christina de Souza
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[5] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[5] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

There are very few characters I would say I hate but Lady Christina is one of them

[JayPea]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[5] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[5] Romana I
[5] Romana II
[5] Nyssa
[5] Tegan Jovanka
[5] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[5] Rose Tyler
[5] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Astrid Peth
[1] Lady Christina de Souza
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[5] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[5] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

Christina is barely a companion

[MrColdStream]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[3] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[5] Romana I
[5] Romana II
[5] Nyssa
[5] Tegan Jovanka
[5] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[5] Rose Tyler
[6] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Astrid Peth
[1] Lady Christina de Souza
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[5] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[5] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

Donna is my girl! Go Donna!

Meanwhile, Katarina is barely a character at all.

[deltaandthebannermen]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[3] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[5] Romana I
[5] Romana II
[6] Nyssa
[5] Tegan Jovanka
[5] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[5] Rose Tyler
[6] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Astrid Peth
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[5] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[5] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

Love Nyssa - GOAT. But bye bye Christina - winner of ‘audio spin off no one asked for’.

[BillFiler]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[3] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[5] Romana II
[6] Nyssa
[5] Tegan Jovanka
[5] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[3] Rose Tyler
[6] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Astrid Peth
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[5] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[5] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

[Tian]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[3] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[5] Romana II
[6] Nyssa
[3] Tegan Jovanka
[5] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[6] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Astrid Peth
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[5] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[5] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

[CommanderBayban]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[3] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[5] Romana II
[6] Nyssa
[3] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[6] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Astrid Peth
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[5] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[3] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

Let’s go Peri!

[uss-genderprise]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[3] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[5] Romana II
[6] Nyssa
[3] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[6] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[3] Astrid Peth
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[3] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

I personally wouldn’t have evn put Astrid and Adelaide on this list. I think we should kick them off before any proper companions.

[BSCTDrayden]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[3] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[5] Romana II
[6] Nyssa
[3] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[7] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[1] Astrid Peth
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[3] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

Agreed with above so deducting Astrid points and giving points to Donna my beloved

[dema1020]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[1] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[6] Romana II
[6] Nyssa
[3] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[7] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[1] Astrid Peth
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[3] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

I agree with @MrColdStream - Katarina is barely a character, much less a companion worth talking about.

[nyssaoftraken]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[1] Katarina
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[6] Romana II
[7] Nyssa
[3] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[7] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[3] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

[-1] Astrid Peth

I can tell this is going to get nearly impossible…

[Daximili]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[6] Romana II
[7] Nyssa
[4] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[7] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[5] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[3] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

Carn Tegan!

[shauny]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[5] Sara Kingdom
[5] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[6] Romana II
[7] Nyssa
[4] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[5] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[7] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[3] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[6] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[3] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

Here to protect River, my beloved

[SophieScarlet]

Not me being too late to defend my Lady Christina and Mother Kylie!

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[5] Sara Kingdom
[3] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[6] Romana II
[7] Nyssa
[4] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[6] Mel Bush
[5] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[7] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[3] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[6] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[3] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

[DarthGallifrey]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[5] Sara Kingdom
[3] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[6] Romana II
[7] Nyssa
[4] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[6] Mel Bush
[6] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[7] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[1] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[6] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[3] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

[Speechless]

[5] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[5] Sara Kingdom
[3] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[6] Romana II
[7] Nyssa
[4] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[6] Mel Bush
[7] Ace
[5] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[7] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[1] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[6] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[1] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

I feel war a-brewing, this is going to be close.

Ace is one of my favourite characters ever written, especially if you’re going by the Big Finish canon.

Yaz however isn’t a character, she is just a presence that is in stories to fill a role.

[VoRus1]

[6] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[5] Sara Kingdom
[3] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[6] Romana II
[7] Nyssa
[4] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[6] Mel Bush
[7] Ace
[3] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[7] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[1] Adelaide Brooke
[5] Amy Pond
[6] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[1] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

I really hope Susan is appearing in the next season (and I think she will do). Don’t like the idea of downvoting anyone, but Grace Holloway has literally been only in 1 story, so is she really a companion lol?

[Meep]

[6] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[5] Sara Kingdom
[3] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[6] Romana II
[7] Nyssa
[4] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[6] Mel Bush
[7] Ace
[3] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[8] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Amy Pond
[6] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[1] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

[-1] Adelaide Brooke

Agreed with @uss-genderprise, Adelaide shouldn’t count as a proper companion.

[TrakeniteAdventuress]

[6] Susan Foreman
[5] Barbara Wright
[5] Vicki
[5] Sara Kingdom
[3] Dodo Chaplet
[5] Polly
[5] Victoria Waterfield
[5] Zoe Heriot
[5] Liz Shaw
[6] Jo Grant
[6] Sarah Jane Smith
[5] Leela
[6] Romana I
[6] Romana II
[7] Nyssa
[5] Tegan Jovanka
[6] Peri Brown
[6] Mel Bush
[7] Ace
[1] Grace Holloway
[4] Rose Tyler
[8] Donna Noble
[5] Martha Jones
[5] Amy Pond
[6] River Song
[6] Clara Oswald
[5] Bill Potts
[1] Yasmin Khan
[5] Ruby Sunday

Grace is barely a companion, so she can go. In terms of who I want to win, go Nyssa and Tegan!