Episode Discussion: Wish World

We sort of did today.

/hj

9 Likes

Mine too probably
Missy > Delgado > War

2 Likes

Lol fair. Definitely a bigger fan of Sir Derick Jacobi, Michelle Gomez, and Sacha Dewan more. I do have John Sims nostalgia tho lol.

4 Likes

Delgado is high up there for me too.

1 Like

I like the Master, but I’m actually really glad we have the Rani and Omega instead in this finale, to be honest. He/she has been hogging the time lord villain spotlight for way too long, and the New Who version is a bit too prone to bouts of ā€œlook how crazy and evil I amā€ for me. Give me some other time lord villains with different modus operandi - I would love to see the Meddling Monk, Morbius or Rassilon as villains over the Master, personally.

17 Likes

Simms was great in World Enough And Time/The Doctor Falls. Everything before that… um…

7 Likes

Yeah I’d say this has been a pretty solid season! Lux is one of my fav episodes now. I’d like a satisfying finale, we’ll see what happens.

1 Like

For all the faults I have with this, at least it isn’t Daleks / Cybermen / Master again.

I can’t help but think the Rani is just written as ā€œRTD’s female Masterā€ though.

13 Likes

That reveal blew my MIND.

3 Likes

I honestly have no issue with that myself

1 Like

Then why not just make her the Master?

I’m glad some are happy with this characterisation of the Rani, but it falls short for me. If I can envisage her as basically the Master or any other stock campy villain, it’s a failure in my view.

14 Likes

Agreed tbh I love the War Master a lot. I’m not sure who my favourite is, either him or Missy I’d say. I do really like Crispy too, but I’d place all even Kisgart above Simm :sob:

3 Likes

17 Likes

I think ultimately I agree with you that her characterisation isn’t what I hoped it’d be, but then I didn’t have hight hopes for it to begin so I’m choosing to just be like yayyyy the Rani!!! And I’ll conveniently gloss over bits I didn’t like [1]


  1. ex lovers???:face_vomiting: give me a break Rusty ā†©ļøŽ

12 Likes

But she was different from the master. Much more planning and less craziness. I would definitely say that she heve different characteristics then the Master, at least different from all new Who masters.

6 Likes

I had fun watching this episode. No, it’s not perfect, and I definitely do have some things I can complain about (I agree the Rani felt a little like Missy), but I think I’ll leave my review for after next week. I mostly enjoyed it, I think it’s visually quite striking (giant skeletons!), and as an episode on its own it’s really not too bad.

Not sure if it’s me you’re thinking of, but I mentioned this in my review of Lucky Day. I definitely feel like RTD doesn’t know how to let disabled people just exist in his stories without their disabilities being a part of the narrative. Honestly, the outsider camp in this episode niggled me a little. Something about the writing feels… I don’t want to say performative, but I’m not sure there’s a better word.

17 Likes

ā€œMuch more planning?ā€ The Master disguised himself as Razor for 10 years whilst living with Bill and infiltrating the Mondasian ship. He came up with the Mr Saxon scheme and built the Paradox machine. Missy took hold of the Nethersphere. The Master has planned a lot, as much as the Rani has.

Less craziness? Maybe a little, but it was still a fairly hammy performance with hammy lines. Complete with a little dance number, talk of them being ex-lovers, hints of a flirtatious nature.

Yeah, she’s doing experiments of sorts but then she could easily be swapped out for ā€˜the Master’ and, honestly, what changes? At its core, nothing. I understand the Rani is a bit more of a blank slate, but nothing so far has really sold me on this character being distinct and different to the Master in a way which makes sense that this is her story and her scheme. I dunno.

17 Likes

So in a little over an hour next week we have to:
Deal with the two Ronnies Rani’s
Reintroduce & defeat Omega
Deal with Susan
Deal with whatever’s going on with Poppy
Sort out Conrad
Get Belinda home
Do something with Kate, Mel, Hebe Shirley and Ruby?

I just fear its going to be a bit too much :sob:

16 Likes

Just consume and look at the pretty VFX, Jamie.

9 Likes

She’s back in this episode. Just calls herself Rani now…

4 Likes