Episode Discussion: The Robot Revolution

One thing I hadn’t commented on, incidentally.

I actually didn’t particularly like Allen in the initial scene. I didn’t like the “girls aren’t good at math” crack, those certificates are really kinda scams[1], he was trying too hard to impress her and was being pushy and I just generally didn’t care much for him. I didn’t think that’d be important, but…


  1. IIRC, generally the star name is only registered in a database in that particular companies database. Company goes out of business, and then it’s registered nowhere… It’s similar to the whole “become a lord” scam. ↩︎

17 Likes

Yeah, that first scene is much stronger on a second watch.

9 Likes

It’s got a bit of the Dot and Bubble touch there, I think, with that scene.

8 Likes

That is a good comparison.

7 Likes
6 Likes

Some interesting points there!

I definitely am enjoying the dynamic between Fifteen and Belinda.

6 Likes

Yeah, I feel like it’s something I really needed in a companion.

Companions that aren’t traveling with the Doctor by choice so much as the Doctor is having trouble getting them home is something we used to see, but not so much these days, and she’s got elements of several former companions that I liked. Martha and Tegan stand out as influences, for example.

11 Likes

ratings are out ! worth noting obviously lots of us watched on iplayer which isn’t included until much later!
https://x.com/supertv247/status/1911347150417469845?s=46

5 Likes

Please do not take as a criticism. It really isn’t meant as such, and I fully appreciate your meaning by using the word. I just love language and so feel compelled to share this quirky little fact because it makes me smile. :blush:

It is a little quirk of language that I enjoy immensely when the word “whelming” means basically the same as “overwhelming”. The application of ‘over’ as a prefix doesn’t change the overall meaning…

…and, either way, it’s infinitely preferable to being underwhelmed. :grin:

7 Likes

(where I learned about “whelmed”, from Dick Grayson Robin himself :wink: )

4 Likes

17 Likes

2 million is a really strong number for a show that was released on iPlayer earlier in the day, and the target audience don’t watch live TV.

And for context, scroll through some of these recent ratings, I see only a couple shows that actually go over 2 million here:

10 Likes

You wont be watching Lux or writing a review?

3 Likes

That is great

4 Likes

The sky is falling, etc.

5 Likes

No but but but Doctor Who does badly and is failing because of woke !!! What about my bad faith narrative !!!

14 Likes

Yeah, it’s not a new episode of Doctor Who without people posting about how bad the ratings were…

12 Likes

All we are going to see is people saying that this is the end because these were the lowest-ever overnight ratings. And these people ignore the fact that it’s been on iPlayer the entire day, so those numbers are much more important. Not to mention D+ everywhere else.

Overnight ratings mean nothing these days.

18 Likes

Is it really new DW if the ratings weren’t the worst they’ve ever been/fine/the show is cancelled/it’s the best/the Doctor is regenerating/the writing/directing/acting/cg is the worst/best it’s ever been??

17 Likes

They’re cute when they’re young, but wait til they grow up…

:laughing:

21 Likes