This elimination game is for the 20 highest rated DWTV stories here on TARDIS Guide! Which one is your favourite? Which do you think are overrated?
To Upvote, add 1. To Downvote, subtract 2. 20 hour between posts.
[5] Heaven Sent
[5] Midnight
[5] World Enough and Time
[5] The Doctor Falls
[5] City of Death
[5] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[5] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[5] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[5] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[5] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars
[5] Genesis of the Daleks
[5] Utopia
[5] Heaven Sent
[5] Midnight
[5] World Enough and Time [6] The Doctor Falls
[5] City of Death
[5] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[5] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[5] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[5] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[5] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars [3] Genesis of the Daleks
[5] Utopia
[5] Heaven Sent
[5] Midnight
[5] World Enough and Time
[6] The Doctor Falls [3] City of Death
[5] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[5] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[5] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[5] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[5] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars
[3] Genesis of the Daleks [6] Utopia
heck this is going to be tough. pinky promise to count properly this time
[5] Heaven Sent
[5] Midnight
[5] World Enough and Time
[5] The Doctor Falls [4] City of Death
[5] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[5] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[5] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[5] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[5] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars [1] Genesis of the Daleks
[6] Utopia
[5] Heaven Sent
[5] Midnight
[5] World Enough and Time
[6] The Doctor Falls
[4] City of Death
[5] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances [3] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[5] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks [6] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[5] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars
[1] Genesis of the Daleks
[6] Utopia
[5] Heaven Sent
[5] Midnight [6] World Enough and Time
[5] The Doctor Falls
[4] City of Death
[5] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[3] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[5] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[5] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars
[6] Utopia
[-1] Genesis of the Daleks has been exterminated already!
[3] Heaven Sent
[5] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[5] The Doctor Falls
[4] City of Death [6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[3] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[5] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[5] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars
[6] Utopia
[3] Heaven Sent [6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[5] The Doctor Falls
[4] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[3] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek [3] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[5] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars
[6] Utopia
[3] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[5] The Doctor Falls [5] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[3] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[3] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[5] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars [4] Utopia
[4] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time [3] The Doctor Falls
[5] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[3] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[3] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[5] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars
[4] Utopia
[5] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[4] The Doctor Falls
[5] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[3] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek [1] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[5] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars
[4] Utopia
[5] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[4] The Doctor Falls
[5] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances [4] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[1] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games [3] The Parting of the Ways
[5] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars
[4] Utopia
[3] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[4] The Doctor Falls
[5] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[4] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[1] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[3] The Parting of the Ways [6] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars
[4] Utopia
It’s like choosing a favourite child!
There’s a typo here, The Doctor Falls should read The Doctor’s Wife. Could one of the moderators please fix it.
[3] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[4] The Doctor Falls [6] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[4] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[1] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[5] The War Games
[3] The Parting of the Ways
[6] Vincent and the Doctor
[5] The Waters of Mars [2] Utopia
It’s not my favourite on the list, but criminal that it’s been downvoted already, so I’ve got to help it out
Probably my favourite Classic on the list (not that there’s much competition
[3] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[4] The Doctor Falls
[6] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[4] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek [3] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[6] The War Games
[3] The Parting of the Ways
[6] Vincent and the Doctor [3] The Waters of Mars
[2] Utopia
Turn Left is too good to be eliminated this early, so I’ll add point to it. The Waters of Mars is great (there is literally not a single bad story in the list), but I’ll downvote it simply because I don’t really like all of that Time Lord Victorius ark, although I do understand why Tenth Doctor could have such thoughts at the end of his series
[1] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[4] The Doctor Falls
[6] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[4] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek [4] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[6] The War Games
[3] The Parting of the Ways
[6] Vincent and the Doctor
[3] The Waters of Mars
[2] Utopia
[2] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[4] The Doctor Falls
[6] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[4] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[4] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[6] The War Games
[3] The Parting of the Ways
[6] Vincent and the Doctor
[3] The Waters of Mars
[3] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[4] The Doctor Falls
[6] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[4] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[4] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[6] The War Games
[3] The Parting of the Ways
[6] Vincent and the Doctor [1] The Waters of Mars
[4] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[4] The Doctor Falls
[6] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[4] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[4] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[6] The War Games [1] The Parting of the Ways
[6] Vincent and the Doctor
[1] The Waters of Mars
It’s great, but Parting of the Ways is definitely the weak link here.
I’ll never understand the vendetta against Heaven Sent
[5] Heaven Sent
[6] Midnight
[6] World Enough and Time
[4] The Doctor Falls
[6] City of Death
[6] Blink
[5] The Doctor Dances
[4] The Empty Child
[5] Dalek
[4] Turn Left
[5] The Night of the Doctor
[5] Forest of the Dead
[5] Remembrance of the Daleks
[6] Silence in the Library
[6] The War Games
[1] The Parting of the Ways [4] Vincent and the Doctor
[1] The Waters of Mars
I’ve never really understood the love that Vincent and the Doctor gets. It’s ending scene is certainly brilliant, but it’s not close to anything else on this list. I certainly wouldn’t choose it over Utopia.
