Your Favourite UNIT Scientific Advisor?

Inspired by the discussion about Morris Gibbons today, I decided to make a poll to find out who our favourite UNIT scientific advisor is. As we all know, UNIT likes to hire a person who knows everything about time, space and aliens. This person has usually been the Doctor, but there have been plenty of others as well.

So, who’s your favourite? Who would you like to see more of in the future, and who should be given a go at the title?

Note that I’ve included the Doctor as one entity for simplicity’s sake. Three and Four were the main ones, but Kate Lethbridge-Stewart later confirmed that the Doctor has always remained on UNIT’s payroll as their scientific advisor, so this could concern every post-Three incarnation.

The list is based on the Wiki article.

You get three choices!

  • Rachel Jensen (Remembrance of the Daleks - not technically UNIT, but a precursor)
  • Anne Travers (Memories of Tomorrow)
  • Liz Shaw
  • The Doctor
  • River Song (The Blood Woods)
  • Kaleidoscope (Kaleidoscope)
  • Elizabeth Klein (Dominion)
  • “Jane Fonda” Iris (Interference - Book Two)
  • Dr Louise Rix (Time Flies)
  • Colonel Emily Chaudhry (The Wasting)
  • Malcolm Taylor (Planet of the Dead)
  • Petronella Osgood
  • The War Master (Master of Worlds)
  • Shirley Bingham
  • Morris Gibbons
0 voters
6 Likes

I am truly struggling with all this anti-Morris sentiment.

5 Likes

I am struggling with Kate Stewart’s employment policies regarding minors :wink:

14 Likes

The Doctor being a not even close third is incredibly funny to me

10 Likes

Me too!

(character limit)

7 Likes

I’ll stand with @Tian forever here even if no-one else will, Morris is annoying…

Rachel Jensen forever for me <3

10 Likes

And we were getting along so well…

3 Likes

The answer’s always going to be Osgood for me, but I must say I’m with @Tian and @sircarolyn, I wasn’t a fan of Morris in the finale, I think we could have spent more time with Rose or given the Vlinx more to do instead of introducing a rather annoying child genius.

11 Likes

You mean you don’t like Rachel :pleading_face::pleading_face: :squinting_face_with_tongue:

5 Likes

Well Liz obviously and I quite liked Shirley too. And I’m sure I’ll fall deeply in love with Rachel once I actually listen to Counter Measures

7 Likes

I do - but she isn’t a UNIT scientific advisor… :eyes:

6 Likes

Liz, the Doctor, and Osgood. Shirley is fun, but being in only one story makes her a little hard to judge. I’m firmly of the stance that Moris is both annoying and a terrible fit for UNIT (I don’t care how smart he is, that is a whole ass child and he shouldn’t have a job, especially one as dangerous as this).

8 Likes

I mean technically you’re right and I agree with you but I am a simple person, I see Rachel Jensen and I am going to vote for her :squinting_face_with_tongue:

8 Likes

I wasn’t even going to include her initially but then I thought of you and wanted to make you happy and decided to extend the invitation to her :wink:

8 Likes

Oooo, I don’t even know who half these people are. Osgood is by far and away my favourite of the scientific advisors, even if originally she was just a lovable fan insert :slight_smile: at first. From what little of Liz I’ve scene (one day I’ll finish Classic) she knows here stuff and is a great addition to the show, it also helps that she gets a lot of screentime by virtue of S7 being heavily UNIT focused. The Doctor gets a pity 3rd place by being the only one left (sorry River), but hey, at least Kate gets to say he’s on the payroll.

5 Likes

Just had too many others I wanted to acknowledge.

Anne Travers is great, but you have to read the Lethbridge-Stewart line to know that, I think.

4 Likes

Whyyyyy did they add an annoying child when they should have just got Osgood back?

Osgood is the best. I like Shirley but don’t know her well enough. I will always vote for River Song :winking_face_with_tongue:

15 Likes

I really need to get into more Iris stuff, because the Jane Fonda gag sounds so funny. Love the limited BF stuff I’ve heard from her!

Agree with Shauny, Osgood should be back by now. Shirley should be Hebe… :sob:

6 Likes

Whyyyyy did they add an annoying cosplay nerd when they should have just got Malcolm back? :sob:

7 Likes

You take that back!! Osgood is amazing.

14 Likes