Working on my first proper fanfiction, would love feedback 😊

I’d really appreciate some advice on my writing. Technically it’s my second fanfic, but my first ā€œproperā€ one imo. Started it last night (been in my head a few years), and I like it but I’m insecure over the quality (stupid, I know, as if art has an objective quality). But I’d appreciate it if anyone has any comments. It’s intended to be quite long, and this is just an intro snippet. No spoilers are in the snippet either. It’s around 800 words atm.

I’ll publish it and several others to AO3, but rn I’m just insecure. And it might be a while because I need to get over my inability to start projects. Still haven’t even thought of a good title :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

It’s a Torchwood fic, with original characters (though Syriath and Suzie, and a few others appear later on), which takes place in The Nethersphere. I take some creative liberties with the settings/lore.

Summary

The Sunset Years bar sat at the edge of The City, overlooking the sea that stretched out, beyond, into the lifeless blackness. Dark waves lapped at the silver chains wrapped around Lottie’s boots, the foam pooling at her ankles. Save for the trickling of rainwater, and the soft electrical whirring of the neon-orange ā€œSunset Yearsā€ sign behind her, the night would prove itself a quiet one.
Lottie slowly wandered following the shoreline, as she had done many previous nights before. Retracing her footsteps in the silver sand, it almost lulled her into a peaceful trance, lost within her mind yet not in thought. A passenger within her own body.
It was the bite of the cool winds that abruptly shook her from her serene daze, and she took in her whereabouts.

Lottie had come to the furthest reach of The City. Before her, the neon-lit streets followed the curvature of the dome. What Lottie once would’ve called the sky no longer existed, as above her, there was only The City. Lottie gazed at the only horizon she would ever lay her eyes on again- the only horizon any of them would ever lay their eyes on again- that which offered nothing but an endless void that was the blackened sea. The City wrapped around itself, the towers reaching downwards like the great fangs of a beast, or like tears from the heavens- she thought-, all converging towards the single gaping maw of the horizon. There was nothing but The City, and The City was eternal.

The sand satisfyingly crunched wetly beneath her boots as she gradually crossed her way over to The Sunset Years Bar. Lottie moved as if guided by a gentle unseen force, not hurrying, not drifting, but caught in a strange dance of her own making- where every step felt purposeful, yet detached from the world around her - a slow deliberate twirl, as if falling within a dream.

Approaching The Sunset Year’s balcony, the young girl caught herself, and began to shake her jacket, skirt, and boots free of any sand - not unlike a cat shaking itself of rainwater.

The bar’s woodwork had worn and knackered with age, clearly having been built much prior to the surrounding buildings, which arose like dark obelisks, towering, ominous, as if Lottie were lost in a Redwood at night. The only signs of life, the light illuminating from the windows, like a dwelling of fireflies, taking refuge in the forest. Some of the bar’s neon lettering had tilted, flickering yellow in an effort to survive, and casting beams of gold into the shallow sea below. Along the balcony were real- physical- papered posters, advertising movies of an era long passed, which caught Lottie’s eye. It seemed to be an Old Western movie, a lost sequel to a plethora of other films - films she recognized, from before she came to The City. This confused her somewhat as her memories seemed blurred and hastily meshed together without care for structure nor time. And rather like an echo, she feared they would soon begin to fade.

Between her fingers, she let the edge of the poster flitter in the wind, as she pondered the ultimate fate of the deceased stars the advertisement heralded. Had their lives been fulfilling? Were they happy, in the end?
No -shaking her head - she couldn’t allow herself to ruminate on their tales, for her own fortitude’s sake. At least not tonight. Better to be lost in her own mind, drifting - safer even- for the time being.

ā€œYou all-right, Love?ā€ hollered the bartender, ā€œLittle thing like you, shouldn’t be out so late.ā€
A woman, sat on one of the outdoor bar stools- tsked in response, ā€œWay to attract customers Deus,ā€ she giggled, ā€œand besides, I could do with some company.ā€ The woman patted a stool next to her, waving Lottie over.
ā€œThy dunt need any other company than me!ā€ Deus playfully retorted, a teasing glint in his eyes as he finished drying a small glass.
ā€œSimmer darnā€, she said, watching as Lottie took a seat, quietly muttering her thanks. ā€œMe name’s Dixie,ā€
ā€œLottie.ā€ a brief, scripted smile, ā€œSorry, but I’m not really here to drink. Just looking for a place to stay.ā€
Deus leaned over the counter, himself smiling too, albeit ruefully, ā€œNo one comes ā€˜ere to drink, Love. Not anymore.ā€ For a moment, his eyes got lost in the black sea, retreating backwards into his mind. His face fell.
It was then that Lottie noted how Dixie tapped her ruby-painted fingernails on the bar counter, disrupting Deus from his haze. ā€œOh yes… Er- a couple rooms upstairs,ā€ he cleared his throat, ā€œAre you sure I can’t get either of you two anything? It’d be a right shame y’know, if you don’t stay a bit- I mean - it’d be like old times, eh?ā€ The bartender punctuated his words with a big, hopeful grin, ear- to-ear.
ā€œI didn’t drink back then either,ā€ Lottie shrugged, not making eye-contact, ā€œI guess an orange juice would be niceā€¦ā€
ā€œRight then!ā€ He clapped his paw-like hands together in joy.
ā€œAnd just a cider for me, thanksā€ Dixie called.
ā€œJust like the ones Mam used to have?ā€
Dixie chuckled, ā€œAye, just like Mam’sā€

Thanks for reading the snippet too, and pls be honest =)

2 Likes

Currently listening to Mind of the Hodiac to feel slightly better about my insecurities :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

2 Likes

Hey, that’s totally valid, insecure can be such a pain in the arse at times. I mean, I have this for sure, otherwise I’d post Fanfics on here every Week haha. Best thing you can do is take the risk and try yourself out with it over time, if possible, but of course no pressure on that one! Take your time and do it only if you are comfortable that Way.

Read the small Snippet and I like it, since it’s a rather long one (as you say), I am not quite sure of the overall plot, but I think it’s written well so far for sure! Can’t comment much on how it holds up at being a Torchwood Thingy, considering it being just a Snippet and my unexperienced Knowledge of Torchwood, but I think you did great! Excited to read more in the Future!

2 Likes

Thanks for reading, and you should definitely post yours here (I’m very biased towards everyone seeing ur stories too :blush:).

and yeah, I think the plot is solid in my head, I’m just paranoid over the writing itself. I know some sentences are a bit lengthy and wordy, they need refining. And spotting things that I wouldn’t notice is better if I ask other people. Like whether it flows, I suppose.

2 Likes

Hah very valid! I did actually post a few back then but it’s been a while, don’t think any of them are very good but yeah.

As for your Concern: That’s more than valid! I always have this Fear myself, that’s why I started to write down the Important Story beats, beat for beat, as a Baseline. Knows silly but gosh does this help feeling more secure and less paranoid to translate it to Page. Besides that, remember that Rewriting exists! You are just doing Draft 1, it being weaker is okay and at times good! You can always later go back and change Things up if needed!

Can’t really speak much on the Flow, as I do have to know where the Story is leading to judge it.

As for if it’s wordy: I can see what you mean by that, but also remember for some Stories it can enhance it! Especially when writing in Thoughts of our Characters, more shorter sentences can greatly make you understand a Character, some longer can do the same. But again just a bit of a rambley Point, I do hope you get what I am trying to say with that! Don’t think you are too wordy, but again hard for me to properly judge it by that Snippet, I must admit. Either way, good luck to you!!

1 Like

I understand you, don’t worry :heart::blush:

So gotta write more and redraft (I’m usually used to the whole ā€œno beta we die like menā€ mindset, but I know that’s not ideal :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:)

1 Like

It’s one that doesn’t work for too long, I’d argue but then again no approach is wrong as long as you have fun with it!

1 Like

I’ll bookmark this topic for tomorrow, I’d love to give you feedback!

2 Likes

That’s good! And I mean that!

The prose is really lovely, and I can’t wait to read more!

Well done!

2 Likes

Thanks, I think I have perfectionist issues but only the bad ones. I’ll think it’s alright, when I write, then a few hours later I’ll think it’s dreadful.

2 Likes

I have the exact same problems :hugs:

2 Likes