What is your most controversial opinion?

That’s okay, it’s all part of my alternate Whoniverse headcanon where we received every episode, just not in the same order, and not necessarily written exactly the same way. In it, Graham and Ryan are Companions first, reducing the crowded TARDIS, and then, since Ryan and Yaz know each other, she’s introduced somewhere in Series 12 (halfway through, perhaps), so we get that new Companion wonder again. Then, when Graham and Ryan’s story has run its course, they depart and we focus on 13/Yaz, and since we just had a new Companion added only a few episodes previously, we don’t need Dan for Flux. I would keep PotD, but instead of having it be a Doctor regeneration story, it would be a Master regeneration story, with Dhawan escaping or disappearing at the climax in the midst of their regeneration, so we don’t see the new face. We would also have a cool look at every incarnation of The Master like the one for The Doctor that included Shalka. This BBC Centenary episode would lead off the Year of the 60th Specials, with Whittaker having to deal with the burgeoning return of the pantheon while navigating a possible relationship with Yaz in their awkward yet endearing fashion.

This would of course necessitate rearranging episodes across all the seasons, moving the strongest team episodes to the period in S12 where all four characters were together, and stories that would be stronger with just Graham and Ryan to the beginning of 13s run, with the strongest Yaz episodes moved to the end (unless it’s one better served with the full team).

12 Likes

I like this - but we can’t have a universe with no Dan! /lh

6 Likes

I completely agree! In my headcanon, Dan is in a couple of episodes, maybe even 3 or 4, but not the whole time.

5 Likes

I’d really like to give Jodie’s era a rewatch. I sort of fell off during the last season, but at that time in my life I wasn’t really in a headspace to watch Doctor Who in general, so I’d like to go back and see it with fresh eyes. Even if my opinion of it doesn’t change, it still definitely has merit for all the reasons you mentioned. I’ve never understood the intense hate some people have for it.

7 Likes

For people who have read the NSAs, I’m not a fan of Prisoner of the Daleks. I thought it had a few standout moments, but felt it wasn’t a great novel as a whole.

6 Likes

Speaking of NSAs, I really don’t like Only Human

8 Likes

You know what I’m going to say…

Palatine voice Do it

4 Likes

Palatine.
He’s like Palpatine, but everyone’s buddy :blush::wink:

5 Likes

I think context is also key. 2005 introduced the bronze Dalek design which fans unanimously loved. I don’t see much wrong with it, and it became iconic as soon as it appeared really. We also have the TARDIS interior, the Doctor’s sonic, etc. which - like them or hate them - were fixed things for the first 2 new Doctors in years.

Then Moffat’s era kicks off and everything changes - new TARDIS prop, new TARDIS interior, new sonic screwdriver, new title sequence, new theme variant (although, granted, it subtly changed mid-RTD as well), new logo, new aesthetic…

The only things unchanged were the Weeping Angels and most of the monsters in the Pandorica alliance.

I think fans at the time felt the Dalek redesign was unnecessary, and maybe just a change too far. I recall mixed reactions to the new TARDIS interior but the prop itself went down well, along with the new sonic, etc. But then those Daleks appeared and, cynically but honestly, fans went “ew they look so wrong - and they’ve probably only changed them for merchandising reasons.” Which, yes, will have played a part, but the shock of (a) the primary colours and (b) the bizarre proportions - namely the awkward hunchback - just led to a bit of a storm, since every other change had mostly gone down favourably. [Plus I’d argue the direction of the episode - an ugly set where the new Daleks are literally wheeled out as if in a commercial, didn’t help.] If fans were ambivalent about some of the changes, none were as egregious as the new Dalek design, is what it felt like. Then they came out and said “these are replacing the old Daleks” and, yep, people weren’t happy. (Although I seem to recall it was less “mad outrage”, and more just everyone lining up to take the piss - Power Ranger music videos with them, people liking them to Teletubbies, etc.)

I think there was sound logic behind redesigning them, but I just feel that maybe if they’d introduced them as a higher ranks to the bronze (and that the bronze Daleks would still feature in the show), there wouldn’t have been the outcry there was? Maybe? Hard to truly know! But I recall at one stage even DWM did a big cover feature about it, which I think only validated this rift between opinions and probably made a large swathe of fans feel vindicated (“even the official magazine is covering this design and its public reaction”).

Following the reception of the Dalek casing redesign first seen in Victory of the Daleks, this issue covered the rift between those who were in favour of and against adopting the New Dalek Paradigm design as the new standard.

Apologies for the ramble. Tiny addendum: it does feel like quite small fry looking back, but 2010 was still the revival in its infancy… and also the first major change (not the format, but lots of design aesthetic changes and redesigns) since 2005 which had been such a success that maybe it feels that something in that first Moffat series was bound to fall short of everything else, which just so happened to be the Dalek design.

This shot also didn’t help the Paradigms either. But hey.

9 Likes

That it is pretty mediocre?

1 Like

We once again find ourselves on opposite sides here my friend :wink:

I love it

5 Likes

The acting is amazing, the atmosphere is fantastic, the music is utterly gorgeous and engaging, the direction is spot on, and the editing is unbelievable.

I get goosebumps every time during that final montage and then the reveal that Gallifrey is on the other side :exploding_head:

My jaw dropped during the ending when I watched it the first time, and I have no idea how long my mouth was open before I remembered to close it. A story that gives me such a viewing experience I just can’t help but love :person_shrugging::blush:

12 Likes

Real. I kept hearing it was one of the best ninth doctor books, and I was pretty underwhelmed when I read it.

3 Likes

Enough about Delta and the Bannermen, what do you think about Heaven Sent?

12 Likes

It suffers from a distinct lack of Ray :wink:

“He’s been ionised!”

6 Likes

I liked 14 - but Jodie’s regeneration felt a bit wasted.
Not sure how i’d have written it - but would have preferred her to pass the torch over to Ncuti

12 Likes

They should have had Jodie as the Watcher!!! (No Idea on the Rest but a.) Bring back the watcher b.) More Whittaker is never bad)

5 Likes

Wasn’t it because Amy was so much taller than the Bronze Daleks that it didn’t look threatening?

I think that’s kinda where they ended up, iirc that’s what it is in Asylum of the Daleks.

Good post thank you, I enjoyed it :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

6 Likes

I think one of the ‘reasons’ was because both Karen Gillan and Matt Smith were tall. Not sure that holds a huge amount of water though - are Jon Pertwee and Tom Baker particularly short?

7 Likes

TARDIS Guide is alright but I’d prefer it if we were CORDIS Guide

3 Likes