TV Club: Tooth and Claw

They’re very strange (but not in the way DW is often strange). Scottish monks mimicking kung fu sterotypes in 19th century Scotland. Really odd given the excellent period setting otherwise.

8 Likes

They really look like what they probably are - the local Cardiff Mixed Martial Arts club. They just don’t fit, as you say, the period setting.

7 Likes

4 Likes

image

5 Likes

Trying to get back into the clubs again after my house move & realised I never posted on this one. This was probably because I didn’t really have much to say about it that hasn’t already been said above.

The “not amused” gag was pure cringe and reminded me of Clara at her worst - it seemed totally out of character for the Rose we had known up to now and seems to imply that Ten is becoming a very bad influence on her.

The treatment of Queen Victoria in this story is another reminder of why I dislike pseudo-historicals with real historical figures so much - & I already know there is far worse to come in that direction! - but it does serve the purpose of setting up Torchwood. Seems very strange thar the Doctor never encountered them before - is this a change to the timeline somehow?

11 Likes

Yes, because it takes the 10th Doctor in his timeline to effect the change leading to Torchwood. This is why they never appear (or are mentioned) in classic Who.

:wink:

8 Likes

I have an explanation. You see, time travel doesn’t actually exist, and the people who made the show back in the 20th century didn’t know about Torchwood, a concept that was invented in the revival era. It’s very difficult for the Doctor to encounter something that wasn’t invented until decades later!

9 Likes

Yes but you still need an in-universe explanation

2 Likes