Okay, here’s my own improved version: https://tiermaker.com/create/doctor-who-tv-movie-audio-companions-1963-2025-15543652
6 Likes
Mags always throws me because she looks so much (to me, anyway) like Claudia Brücken from Propaganda in the 80s:
4 Likes
Turlough’s in the abysmal tier coz he’s abysmally good right?
Right…?
6 Likes
Left out companions I don’t know or don’t really consider companions.
And yes, I left Wilf in, because I am a student of the truth.
6 Likes
Only did the top tier cause I did one yesterday and I mostly agree iwth it. Ace is back in the top spot, but today there’s a notable difference between the Romanas. That rarely happens
4 Likes
No, Wilf is not a companion!!!
(Having the names with the images was really helpful, thanks @SophieScarlet)
5 Likes
Here you go, the true companion ranking…
S tier: All time favourites
A tier: Really great
B tier: Pretty good
C tier: They’re fine
D tier: Not good
5 Likes
Looking at this now, I fear I put Astrid way too high because she’s played by my idol. She should really be like near Ian and Polly.
What if I said Wilf was a companion, but only as a one-off in The End of Time, placing him in a group with Astrid, Jackson/Rosita, Lady Christina, et al.?
6 Likes
Yeah, I don’t dislike him, but I class him as a recurring guest character than as a proper companion
3 Likes
Companions!
(In terms of Clara, I think her arc is brilliantly done, and her exit in Face the Raven is wonderful. That being said, I just find her infuriating with her general know-it-all vibe (which, admittedly, is intentional))
4 Likes
I don’t like it when they don’t have names on the pictures. It is so hard to see sometimes who is who.
2 Likes
What did the Season 19 crew ever do to you? 
6 Likes
Then you might want to check out this Tier list here! Not only made by a TardisGuide Member, but also with names included (and even some of the EU Companions)!
6 Likes
I really don’t like the Fifth Doctor’s companions. Sorry.
5 Likes
Poor K9 being hidden by the Tiermaker Logo
5 Likes
Peri in the “okay” category :o
3 Likes
Yes.
3 Likes