Heres my feelings on companions today. Kudos to Harry Sullivan for being the only man I actively like
4 Likes
The 5DAs are, I think one of Big Finish’s most consistently good ranges, and i look forward to doing the others.
The 8DAs, sadly, do not rank as highly for me
7 Likes
My Fourth and War Doctors rankings based on what I’ve done at the moment.
Also, you’ve made a little mistake in the War Doctor one - you wrote “Today is Tomorrow and Tomorrow is Today”, while the story is actually called “Yesterday is Tomorrow and Tomorrow is Today”
6 Likes
Ah, damn. Thanks for pointing that out, I’ll fix it when I get a chance.
3 Likes
Lucie would go between the Brig and Susan, Audacity ahead of Rose, Naomi ahead of Dodo.
https://tiermaker.com/create/all-tv-doctor-who-companions--some-big-finish-ones-369165
5 Likes
Lol who is that old woman beside Erimem?
1 Like
The Twelve, apparently.
2 Likes
This was really hard! I love the classic and EU companions so much it was so hard to make the dividing choices. Still not certain on this!
Lucie is light orange tier, Naomi and Audacity light blue.
Fitz and Anji obviously red tier! Compassion dark orange, Sam green. Stacy and Ssard both dark blue. I don’t know Gabby or Izzy well enough yet but they’re both on their way to the high tiers!
6 Likes
Always love a good Companion Tierlist, my Opinion will probably change again, but one Thing is for certain, the last Tier stays at the Bottom
7 Likes
Addendum: Lysander and Sally! I’m literally listening to them right now and kinda falling in love with them. Definitely yellow or above! And Klein—orange for sure. (So many companions…)
3 Likes
Faceblind tier is Amy and Erimem. (Only figured out Erimem from Bayban’s comment.)
3 Likes
Facepalming on Amy, but I dont blame myself for Erimem. Isnt she bald?
3 Likes
Method of creating the sections and sorting them was “Gut reaction when I thought of their names”, so yknow, highly scientific and all. No particular order within tiers
4 Likes
First is Sergeant John Benton second is Captain Mike Yates
2 Likes
Actually on second thought Benny is second Missy is third Ace is fourth. Ace! Fourth!! What have things come to
2 Likes
I would put Lucie in the ‘Like a lot’ tier, along with Fitz and Anji, simply because I haven’t done enough of their stuff to really really love their characters. (But I don’t doubt that they’ll get there soon!)
And I’d put Sam in the ‘Dislike’ tier. Would’ve been lower if not for Seeing I lol.
4 Likes
I ranked all of the characters I know (even if I don’t consider them companions). I don’t listen to a ton of Big Finish and the only Classic I’ve watched is An Uneathly Child, so a “don’t know them” tier would take up a ton of space.
6 Likes
