Doctor: No, no, no. Stop it! Look. I was never, ever here. Never! The timelines in the canon are rupturing.
2 Likes
Yeah i know Iāve said it a billion times but theyād genuinely have to pull it off right
I am all here for a Susan return AS LONG AS THEY DO IT RIGHT
Iām not a very pedantic fan tbf and I usually enjoy anything they put out (I even enjoyed Empire of Death apart from the stupid bloody sign that was ridiculous) but if theyāre going to bring back Susan Foreman then we need a GOOD and EXPLAINED return, not just some random ahh cameo
On another note, Iām genuinely so excited for Ruby to return in the finale as I genuinely donāt think her story is overā¦ remember when Maestro said āthis creature is wrongāā¦ there is something more to her I think 
2 Likes
Im sure briggs is gonna hate RTD for it
2 Likes
This will vary for every single fan. They wonāt ever be able to please everyone.
I do agree, though, that a random cameo probably isnāt the best way to bring her back. But, again, context will be key.
3 Likes
Yeah just checked Andrew Evans is now renamed to āāmeglosāā
2 Likes
RTD is just being weird and annoying lately by restricting everything. Sutekhās back! But they only met once beforeā¦ The Toymakerās back! But they only met once beforeā¦
Why? Why do this? Its just pointless and adds nothing.
6 Likes
I doubt Nicholas Briggs will care. Stuff gets glossed over, changed, retconned, ignored, referenced, acknowledged, whatever, all the time. BF and TV Who can still sit side by side.
2 Likes
that wasnt by evans that was by Pat,a fake leaker who got lots of stuff wrong.
1 Like
Yeah I defo see what you mean. Personally I did enjoy the return of the Toymaker and Sutekh but it did all feel very rushed and something was off with the returns
not to repeat this but if we had longer episode times then I feel like there would be more opportunities for RTD to tell these stories how they truly should be told
2 Likes
I liked the returns but why did he purposefully write those lines in which retcons the BF/other eu encounters. Felt unnecessary and it didnāt add anything.
2 Likes
Iām not taking a side here but RTD is telling these stories how he thinks they ātruly should be told.ā But itās literally just his vision. We donāt have to like it or agree with it.
2 Likes
yeah you are right. Personally I love RTDās writing and sometimes it is a lil iffy but I can always see his true vision, whether I like it or not
1 Like
For TV drama. He could use a flashback to The Celestial Toymaker and having the two seemingly only having encountered each other once before made the encounter in The Giggle feel rare, and it was also superficially a nod to the 60s era of Who for the 60th anniversary. It sort of undermines it a bit if they feel they have to go āoh weāve met loads of times.ā
Again, Iām not taking sides here - just playing devilās advocate and seeing it from a potential RTD TV scripting point of view.
4 Likes
Iāll remain optimistic it doesnāt prove its him.
3 Likes
I honestly donāt care what happens as long as we get
Maria, the God of Abysmalness
OR
Professor Rivers, the God of Science
3 Likes
Need another Dimensions in Time where she meets ar Shirl
4 Likes
Donāt forget about Luke Smith, the God of Autism (Iām autistic, and Iām claiming him as one us)!
5 Likes
If this is true: the rumour about baby Poppy being The Doctor and Belindaās daughter, I hope itās kinda like how Jenny was createdā¦ And not anything else. Or maybe the Universeās way of creating a weird hybrid, that poor Susan might have to look after. But I donāt immediately hate the idea. But it doesnāt align with Space Babies at all (yet).
or maybe it is Susan. 15 says he never had kids. Susan could be a displaced Poppy, thatād make sense. Subsequently then given to Fugitive Doctor, highlighting how she became The First Doctor.
3 Likes
Guys, youāre going to kill me, but of everything Iāve read about the ending, I think this is the least confusing and worst, lol. I can draw a line of reasoning for this. Maybe that person who is involved in the ending did experiments with the Doctorās and Belindaās genes. I find this plausible, actually. Not that I like it or anything, but you know when weāre already in deep shit and nothing really shakes me anymore. But letās see how these things can be executed. If theyāre real, you never know.
1 Like