Season 3 - Wishlists & Predictions

How about we do the third Doctors era, take two?

Ground the Doctor for a while, bring on all the UNIT cast we’ve brought back multiple times now (Kate, Mel, Shirley Anne Bingham, etc) just as regulars and base things out of that set. Reuse as many props and sets as we can between shows, go really light on effects and cgi.

Stories now normally span multiple episodes. Sacha Dhawan’s back as the Master… every week. Cast a Doctor who has good chemistry with him. (Actually, just for fun, what if we also brought back Michelle Gomez as Missy, and the two of them are both causing trouble for UNIT and each other? Both are flirting outrageously with the Doctor.)

Alien costumes are now what turned up in an estate sale last week. Running in corridors, quarry’s, filming wherever is convenient.

Crank out the episodes, with a “good enough” approach to filming and minimal retakes. Focus on character work, not so much epic universe ending plots.

11 Likes

I’d be happy if we never saw any of NuUNIT ever again.

13 Likes

Don’t you want to see more of Kate & Ibrahim? Maybe over a season of a 3rd Doctor style show he might say enough words to form a complete sentence.

15 Likes

How about we let Paul Magrs do it? (incredible that they’ve never got him doing an episode!)

9 Likes

I never want to see Cardboard 1 or Cardboard 2 ever again.

I’m baffled that Kate is still a recurring non-character in this show.

6 Likes

I want to se more of Kate and Petronella Osgood

12 Likes

I feel like not seeing them enough is the problem here. Actually give them scenes and dialogue and character development and they are no longer cardboard, and the problem is taken care of.

4 Likes

Kate especially has had over 10 years on and off screen, and I’ve seen little to no improvement. (May be one for the controversial opinion thread.) I’m just bored of the current UNIT set up, and also of Kate. I’d bin it all and either leave UNIT be for a long while, or build from the ground upwards.

10 Likes

I like Kate, but I much prefer her on audio than on TV.

7 Likes

This - there is literally nothing about this current incarnation of UNIT that motivates me to want more of them.

5 Likes

Was literally just thinking this as I read the above posts.

I think the concept of Flux, with the overarching story mostly secondary to the monsters of the week, was actually strong, and I liked Karvanista a lot. As a less sci-fi person, I didn’t love the concept of the Flux itself, but I didn’t dislike it. What let it down for me was the Ravagers.

Yeah! Bring back Osgood!

A less military, more sciencey focus for UNIT would be great. Scientists/engineers (Shirley, Susan, Mel, Morris, Vlinx, maybe Rose) already outnumber military figures (Kate, Ibrahim) among the named characters.

Yes, which really makes a streamer a less than ideal co-production partner for the BBC (as opposed to the CBC or Syfy, or Comedy Central or Oxygen for Ab Fab), because when they’re relying on people retaining their subscriptions, their participation is in turn less reliant on the show itself, and more on the quality of the rest of their catalog. It doesn’t matter how good or bad DW is if there’s nothing else on D+ that Who fans want to watch.

It’s an especially sad state of affairs when you remember DW was created by an immigrant, a woman, and a gay man of color.

5 Likes

I’ll keep ■■■■■■■ saying it, give it to Helen George. She has very provably been able to do a long running, character focused (including incredible focus on women, non-white characters, and families, which clearly Russell has a bit of a yen for in this era) period drama, and Doctor Who has cropped up in it enough times that I have to believe she has some fondness for it.

4 Likes

Do you mean Heidi Thomas? Helen George plays Trixie. Thomas showruns/writes it.

2 Likes

Pinch of salt as ever…

https://www.reddit.com/r/DoctorWhoNews/comments/1l28shj/leaker_andrew_explains_billie_pipers_casting_as/?share_id=mIZYjwQ4dxNd-priCB-q-&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=ioscss&utm_source=share&utm_term=1

6 Likes

BBC a bit concerned currently about how they’re going to continue the show themselves.

I know (iirc) their budget suffered because of the Tories’ shit, but seriously? Come on. It really feels like we’re in a Michael Grade “we have to compete with Star Wars’ special effects or we shouldn’t do it at all” situation.

I don’t even think Russel knows why she has rose’s face yet

May I direct him to forum.tardis.guide for some ideas.

No billie wasn’t even on set. She filmed everything with an incredibly small crew in front of a green screen in London … There were a few alternate takes of Billie’s first lines, I was hoping for a bit more edge but all gave me Jodie vibes

If true, this would suggest that Andrew is quite high up in the production crew, no?

Nothing is confirmed no, billie saw it more of a favour to Russel than anything. She’s happy to do a special or series, but is also fine to just film a quick something in an attempt to help out the show, even if it ends up being no use

Please, PLEASE, God, give me a series with Doctor Billie. I don’t want it to be a trick. I want them to commit to the bit, and more importantly, I want Billie Piper to play the Doctor. Please, God, I’ve been a very good girl and said all my prayers. (I haven’t.)

8 Likes

I can believe Billie just doing this as a favour to RTD & its so obvious that it was a hastily done thing.

I do not see how it would benefit Billie’s career to return to Dr Who for any significant amount of time.

12 Likes

Also its the fact it looked so good before RTD2 anyways like Flux was stunning and that was in Covid!

Not sure if its defo from Andrew, but Andrew definitely has good sources he got everything bang on this season, wild!

10 Likes

Its so obvous from watching the scene, Billie’s head just cut & paste onto Ncuti.

9 Likes

I meant that he’s seen alternate takes, even though the shoot was done with just a small crew.

4 Likes

Not sure the alt takes bit is confirmed from real Andrew or fakedrew. Then again, fakedrew got 13 and Billie correct so :sob:

4 Likes