Questions about how tracking works for the Big Finish main range

(I looked for a site usage forum and this is the closest I could find. If there’s a more appropriate forum for this discussion please point me there).

I’m currently working my way through the main range in chronological order, as well as listening to the Eight Doctor Adventures and a few others. The latest published main range title I’ve listened to is 103 - The Girl Who Never Was and the latest Eighth Doctor Adventure I’ve completed is ‘Dead London’

Based on that the next titles I should be listening to are 104 - The Bride of Peladon in the main range and Max Warp in the Eighth Doctor Adventures.

Instead the titles listed under ‘My Next Story’ are:

  • Big Finish Main Range - 120 - The Magic Mousetrap
  • Main Range: Fifth Doctor - Castle of Fear
  • Main Range: Sixth Doctor - The Raincloud Man
  • The Eighth Doctor Adventures - Orbis

There’s a few stories I need to listen to before I get to those. And those also aren’t the next Fifth or Sixth Doctor stories I need to listen to in the main range. I’ve told the Database which stories I own and which I’ve already listened to so presumably it knows that and it doesn’t seem to be basing it on either of those.

Does anyone know what’s going on please?

It’s entirely possible this is user error but if so I don’t know even where to start in fixing it.

Thanks.

4 Likes

When I look at your profile it looks like the las MR you completed is MR119, not MR103. My next story is based on the last one you listened to and choose the next one in the set.

For example: if I watch An Unearthly Child and then Marco Polo, my next story will be Edge of Destruction, not Dalek.

Hope this helps.

7 Likes

This is correct, I wanted to allow people to skip a story and carry on from where they left off, not for it to always nag to go back to an old story. This is before “skip stories” was available.

Also the reason the Fifth Doctor and Sixth Doctor are there is because there are Sets which allow you to only follow the Main Range by Doctor, if you should wish.

Some people asked for that.

If you’d like to go strictly in order, then “untrack” those sets.

I do need to write a better documentation to explain all this.

Feel free to ask more questions!

10 Likes

If it’s always based on the last one you completed, it does appear to be broken with some sets though. Gallifrey for example has been stuck on the questing beast for me for example since I completed the one before that even though I have completed earlier ones since then, and I think the target collection is stuck for me too?

8 Likes

Aha, thank you, my bad! I’d forgotten I watched Key2Time early so I could check out Graceless.

That explains the next Fifth Doctor recommendation, also.

Re: The other two it looks like I somehow managed to misflag some future stories as ‘Listened’.

Everything looks great now.

It would be a neat feature at some point to be able to just manually set where you’re up to in a series but that’s ideal world stuff.

Thank you for all your help.

7 Likes

If you have listened to something before it does not show up in up next.

For example

I you have watched Daleks before and then watched an unearthly your up next will show Marco Polo even if Daleks is after.

5 Likes

Yeah, but that’s not quite what I mean. With gallifrey for example, I haven’t listened before, I listened up to 2.4 where it always showed me the next one correctly, then I completed damned if you do which is placed at a much later point in the series, and since then I have completed 2.5 and 3.1. So, right now it should show me 3.2 which I have not listened to, yes? But it shows me the one after damned if you do instead. Or am I not understanding correctly how it should work?

8 Likes

That sounds strange. We need @shauny to answer that.

6 Likes

Hi, all the above is resolved and I have a new question about tracking the main range:

Is there a way to track the main range linearly? I’ve been working my way through the main range and the home tracking page was great until I hit around 100 at which point tracking suddenly split into subranges for several individual Doctors.

Is there a way to have a tracker for the main range as a whole? I notice that the stories are allocated to both the subrange and the top level main range so the necessary info is in the database.

Thanks.

4 Likes

You should already be tracking it, it might just be that the next story from it is also the next story from one of the main range: nth doctor sets, the same story won’t appear twice in the next story segment. You can go to each of the sets’ pages and choose there whether or not to track them, that way you can choose to only track the main range in its entirety

6 Likes

Yep, what @Jae said

There is a “Set” containing everything, but there are lots of other sets too which are split into different ways of listening.

You can untrack all the others to only be tracking the main one.

Here is the set:

5 Likes

Ah, okay thanks.

It would be useful to have both sets of trackers going, but if it can only be one, main range it is. :+1:

Thank you.

3 Likes

You can track them all at the same time, if you want, in fact that is the default way it works. It might just not seem that way in the next story segment.
This, for example, is how my next main range story looks because it is both the next main range in general and the next in main range seventh doctor:


It only appears to be in one set at first glance but is actually in both. After I have completed this one, it will split again, showing me both the next one in general, and the next one with the seventh doctor.
I hope that is what you meant, or am I misunderstanding your question?

7 Likes

Thanks Jae,

I figured it was still tracking where I was up to in both sets, I’d just hoped.to be able to display both on the homepage so that I could follow the main track while still seeing where I was up to with each Doctor.

4 Likes

The reason this happens is if more than one set result in the next story being the same story, instead of listing the same story twice it just lists it once.

As soon as you complete that story, if the sets split off into different next stories, you’ll see two again.

Not super intuitive but that is just how it works, at the moment :blush:

5 Likes