Heroes and Monsters Collection

Inspired by the topic about short stories, and my desire to read more, plus @Tian asking for more badges and wanting a new ‘obscure Who’ project, I am going to read all of Doctor Who: Heroes and Monsters Collection and rate them.

Fun fact - one of these stories is one of only 4 stories to get a perfect average 5/5 score on the site. Unfortunately it’s only got 6 ratings, which might be why it’s so skewed, and I’d like to fix that!

Join me! There is a badge! :sparkles:

Ideally we need at least 10 people to rate them all so we get a good view of what the ratings should actually be.

15 Likes

I might join you in this! Sounds fun!

9 Likes

I’ll do it once I’ve finished my TLV marathon!

9 Likes

I made it a good half way through this book earlier this year before being side tracked so this is good motivation to get back to it, though I am busy with two other short story collections and life in general, I am really tempted by that badge so will get back to this!

9 Likes

A badge you say?

10 Likes

It is a bit sad that they did not create new covers in the same style for the stories that did not originate from the Doctor Who Files. Those covers are in a fantastic early 2000 style!

9 Likes

They do feature Eleven and Twelve though so wouldn’t have really fitted.

Also note that the order of the stories in the Set is different to in the book, purely because they re-ordered them and mine is always in release order. Bit annoying but not much I can do about it.

This page has the correct order though!

6 Likes

I know but I think that they could have done it anyway. It would look good!

Finished the first story: The Stranger. I thought that it was good. I don’t find the time war that interesting but this was a nice story with the War Doctor being the Doctor even if he doesn’t see himself as it. I rated 3.5/5

I love this idea and it is fun to have a new project to aim for.

Feels like a “playlist” function would be good to add to the site in the future where stories could be arranged in other orders. Would be great for TLV as well.

10 Likes

We’ve talked about a custom list (or was it set) feature down the line, right? I’ve been wanting to rearrange my Time War listen through for so long…

7 Likes

Yes, it’s on my list to build! At some point! It’s a big list!

8 Likes

Once the new design is launched I’ll list all the new features I have in mind and ask people to vote which ones to prioritise…

8 Likes

New elimination game?

6 Likes

I find it funny how this is @shauny’s thread and he begins it by saying he’s going to read all these stories, only for @Tian to hijack it in his usual manner and get started on it before Shauny! And he’ll probably finish it all before Shauny’s even started :smiley:

9 Likes

I know… I did a bit differently at least. No:

big headlines

and marked the text as spoiler

Also:

THERE IS A BADGE!!! :stuck_out_tongue:

7 Likes

Don’t worry, I fully expected this and encourage it :grin:

I probably will start later today I just feel bad if I spend any time that could be spent working on the site doing anything else… but have to wait in the waiting room later for my mother in law to go to the dentist so I’ll read the first story then!

Hope not, as I’m starting today, but yeah he’ll finish it way before me :grin:

7 Likes

That is not a great mindset to have. That is how you will burn yourself out. It is okay to take time off. We want you for a long time not just for now. You take care of yourself first. The site will never be more important than that. We can wait!

8 Likes

Is there an ebook version of this? I have all the Files but never bothered with the collection - I didn’t realise it had so many extra stories!

Actually, scrub that, I might just see if there is a cheap copy of it on ebay.

5 Likes

If you visit this site called TARDIS Guide, link above it’s a pretty neat site, there’s a link to Amazon where you can find the Kindle version and also paperback. Other stores are available.

7 Likes

Also if you use the Amazon or eBay link on the site I may get a tiny kickback :wink:

6 Likes

Look at what you made me do - I shouldn’t even be shopping at work!

And yes, I went through the link on TARDIS Guide…

10 Likes