General Discussion for Ranking Game

[SweetAIBelle]

@deltaandthebannermen

And yeah, I’m Mr Opinionated about Genesis of the Daleks. I can see everything that makes is ‘good’ but it just doesn’t stir my juices. It’s just so bloody grey.

@deltaandthebannermen

This is a definite 8/10 for me

[deltaandthebannermen]

What are you trying to say about me?

[BSCTDrayden]

I finally forgave you for Heaven Sent so you decided to make me your enemy in a new way, eh?

[deltaandthebannermen]

Making enemies is the only reason I’m here, really.

[BSCTDrayden]

@greyherringgull

I don’t hate genesis but I think it should go because this is an elimination game for losers, so an underdog should win it, not one of the most popular and well-known TV stories.

Trust me; on this forum it’s an underdog

[RandomJoke]

It’s honestly interesting that the one I would want to downvote the most haven’t been touched at all, I think I hadn’t had this with an Elimination Game before!

…hopefully this means I don’t make myself any Enemies if I downvote any of those

[Jamie]

@InterstellarCas

[0] - Joy to the World - Episodes written by Steven Moffat

YESSSS

[TARDIS32]

I don’t know, I think Genesis was the least deserving to go out first on this whole list. I’m not saying it should have won its game, but go out first? No. And that’s how I’m voting, by which was least deserving to lose not most deserving to win.

[uss-genderprise]

Someone better save Cyberwoman or you won’t be seeing me again for a while.

[spacemcguffin]

I was tempted to take it out but it’s more fun to leave it as bait.

[BillFiler]

@uss-genderprise

Someone better save Cyberwoman or you won’t be seeing me again for a while.

@MrColdStream already tried that bluff you know

[TrakeniteAdventuress]

@wishiwashistan

[0] - Cyberwoman - Torchwood Series 1 & 2

Huzzah! A worthy loser

[sircarolyn]

I kind of miss Mrs Coldstream…

[BillFiler]

Don’t we all…

[uss-genderprise]

Welp, I guess this is goodbye. My tumblr is the same username if any of you want to keep in touch.

[SweetAIBelle]

After this elimination game is done, lets go ahead and just put a pause on more elimination games for a while. It’s getting where it’s not as friendly or fun as it was, people are just going into it with a mindset of killing things, and, you know, this last one was supposed to be the break from less intense games.

This was a elimination game about elimination games anyways, making it a fairly good stopping point.

[spacemcguffin]

I’m new here but I’ve sensed a lot of “targeted attacks” and, while I get they’re elimination games, it does feel a bit against the spirit of things if people are just going after the same things every single time.

Maybe there could be a spin on the game - an Appreciation Game, where all the options begin with [2] points and every 20 hours someone can +2 to their favourite and -1 to their least favourite and it becomes a race ~ first to 20 or 30 points wins? Then the race carries on for second place, etc? Might be more of a positive game, encouraging people to upvote their favourites more so than downvoting their least favourites, but still with tactical downvoting?

[SweetAIBelle]

I’d generally prefer not to have the downvoting element at all. Or have the downvoting not result in elimination, say, they can’t go below 0 and still stay in the game and can recover.

[TARDIS32]

Well there isn’t really much of a game without downvoting or eliminating. Maybe a break is what’s needed though, if enough are feeling similarly.

[MrColdStream]

We could also try to come up with a new game altogether and do it for a while.

I also feel like we’ve had an elimination game going all the time. Maybe we could have breaks between every round even when (if) we bring this back.