You know the drill. Everyone gets 2 votes!
Hmm not a lot of ones I like. Went with A Good Man Goes to War and The Zygon Invasion. Honourable mentions to Unicorn and the Wasp and Legend of Ruby Sunday (THAT CLIFFHANGER!!)
“The Unicorn and the Wasp” is one of my favorite episodes, so there is zero competition.
Amy’s choice and The Zygon Invasion are absolutely brilliant episodes, so this is a fairly easy choice.
Amys Choice and Good Man Goes to War
Zygon Invasion was the easiest choice for number 1, number 2 however wasn’t so easy. I think Amy’s Choice, A Good Man Goes to War, and Rings of Akhaten are all amazing episodes. I think out of those 3, Amy’s Choice edges out the victory, very important character development for Amy, a great antagonist, Rory’s ponytail, very good episode.
Zygon Invasion and Rings of Akhaten
The easiest choice so far for me. Amy and Akhaten all the way! Lovely stories.
I really need to rewatch Akhaten because it did nothing for me on broadcast. It committed the cardinal sin, as far as I’m concerned, by boring me.
It bored me the first time around. Every rewatch since it’s captivating me — it’s got that’s empathetic and magical tone I’ve grown to love in Who.
Yeah, I do think it may get better a second time round but somehow I’ve not got around to it.
Oh, there are plenty of episodes I need to rewatch! I’m sure I’ll like Time Heist more on a second viewing. But it’s a matter of time! There’s just so much Big Finish in the world!
I chose Amy’s Choice, because it’s a drastically underrated, incredibly clever, effortlessly stylish emotional rollercoaster, and Unicorn and the Wasp because it’s fun.
Had you asked me a month ago, I might’ve even put The Legend of Ruby Sunday but I rewatched it recently after Season Two left me way colder than Season One. I actually found a good majority of it insufferable, which is new.
It doesn’t really do a whole lot. I love the song and the Doctors speech though!
Some high highs and low lows here. It’s Unicorn for me though!
42 isn’t that bad guys I promise 
42 is fine. Can You Hear Me? on the other hand… 
Idiot’s Lantern (don’t worry, not getting into all that again… this time) and Amy’s Choice because I really dug the look into Eleventh’s psychology and the Eleventh/Amy/Rory relationship dynamic.
Do you know how it feels to be the only one to vote Kerblam!???
Rings of Akhaten all the way. I’m not even using my second vote because nothing can compare.