Favourite Episode 6?

I went for Dalek and Demons of the Punjab, both are great episodes. Though, Extremis is a close runner up.

5 Likes
4 Likes

My top two are easy choices, Dalek (controversial, I know), and The Caretaker, which has always been a comfort story for me.

4 Likes

Dalek and Demons are my choices. Rogue would also be up there, but I was only allowed to pick two.

6 Likes

Voted for Dalek (well duh it’s Shearman) and Demons of the Punjab (best 13 Episode in my Eyes, a brilliant Historical and utterly gorgeous!)
As for the other Episodes: I really enjoy Extremis! I think the Doctor’s Daughter is brilliant and just really underrated. And the Woman who lived is great, I will die on this Hill!
Now with the Story & the Engine, I think it has a good Chance to become a favorite of the 6th Episode Slot for me, but I don’t want to be too quick on that tho.

7 Likes

Shearman is my favorite writer i need him to do more tv

3 Likes

As the song goes, I can’t decide.

6 Likes

Normally I like to do groups of three, but for this one I chose ‘Dalek’ and ‘Demons of the Punjab.’ My third choice would’ve been ‘Extremis,’ and if I had a second group of three, it would’ve been (in no particular order) ‘The Doctor’s Daughter,’ ‘Rogue,’ and ‘The Bells of Saint John.’

5 Likes

Demons of the Punjab is such a moving story, it’s recently become one of my favourite TV episodes since I last rewatched it, probably the best or second-best New Who historical.

Extremis is just brilliant, such an ingenious premise. And it properly starts off the vault arc, and has the Doctor navigating being disabled, and the hilarity of the pope interrupting Bill’s date. What an episode.

10 Likes

Demons of the Punjab and Rogue. Both of them are fantastic. Woman Who Lived and Extremis are contenders for third place.

5 Likes