- Aliens of London
- The Girl in the Fireplace
- Daleks in Manhattan
- Sontaran Stratagem
- Time of Angels
- Doctor’s Wife
- The Power of Three
- Listen
- Before the Flood
- Knock Knock
- Arachnids in the UK
- Nikola Tesla’s Night of Terror
- Village of Angels
- 73 Yards
73 yards. Village of the Angels and Before the Flood were other contenders.
World’s End
Had to go with 73 Yards, but I would have also voted for Before the Flood and Girl in the Fireplace if I had more votes. Quite liked Sontaran Stratagem as well; love Wilf, and getting to see Donna and Martha share an adventure.
Noo I can’t choose two votes!
I still love Before the Flood an awful lot, but 73 Yards would be my other choice.
Only one choice Before the Flood it is!
Doctor’s Wife. Yes, hindsight sucks, but I like the TARDIS as a character in their own right, and Gaiman as a writer is at his best when he’s humanising abstract concepts. Of all the choices available, this one feels the most essential as part of the DW canon (if such a thing existed, lol) because of its depiction of the Doctor/TARDIS relationship.
Before the Flood, easy, taught everyone what a Bootstrap paradox is, what’s not to love . Honourable mention goes to Time of the Angels, Village of the Angels, and Listen for just being very good episodes.
Oh yeah I love that one just wish they did more with Fisher King
ough i like a lot of these, just about managed to pick the girl in the fireplace, but village of angels and the doctor’s wife were strong contenders as well - i know the, well, issues around the latter now, but when i first saw it i adored it - i loved the concept, and the storyline, and i still do to be honest
Before the Flood, for being my favourite televised story. It is not Listen, which is conversely one of the low points of 12’s era
Oh really,I myself love Listen a lot
73 yards, WITH an honorable mention to daleks in manhattan as one of my top 3 martha stories!
Choosing only one option is so hard when other polls give me choices lmao
I think I’ll go with Listen, but there’s so many good choices here
christ again, none of these… Knock Knock is totally an underrated episide to me
A lot of really good episodes on this list. I wish I had at least four or five votes.
Good: Aliens of London, Daleks in Manhattan[1], The Time of Angels
Meh: The Girl in the Fireplace, The Sontaran Stratagem, The Doctor’s Wife, The Power of Three, Listen, Before the Flood, Knock Knock, Nikola Tesla’s Night of Terror, Village of the Angels
Lame: Arachnids in the UK, 73 Yards
sorry for being controversial ↩︎
I went with The Girl in the Fireplace, but Before the Flood, 73 Yards, Village of the Angels…pfft, who am I kidding? Half the entries on that list were in contention for me.
Polls like this should allow for multiple options, that way you get much better results.
It was @Koquillion who made the first few polls, you should have made this the same as the others (or let them create it, it was their idea)
Can’t edit now without resetting the votes.