Episode Discussion: The Robot Revolution

He totally should have added a sofa.

8 Likes

So did i miss anything?

2 Likes

I agree. Giving Season 2 a chance but I felt like Season 1 fast-forwarded or just outright skipped through a lot of development.

10 Likes

Of reasonable comfort.

tumblr_051bf97f8767cd58fba3d05a93f66276_5cc151f3_500

11 Likes

What do you mean?

1 Like

Concept art…

12 Likes

Also, killing a ā€œcalculating animal with tailā€ could easily have consequences, depending on what it was calculating. What if it was actually calculating something for Mrs Flood?

7 Likes

I agree that 10 is probably my ideal number of episode. I feel like it just gives them a bit more breathing room. That being said, I do think its possible to do it in eight. I just sort of got the vibe last time that RTD wasn’t used to writing a season of that length. That might just be me though. While I’m still sort of worried about it, I think between this being the second go around and the fact that season one already laid a lot of ground work, I’ll probably like the pacing better this season.

12 Likes

More often than not, I’ll always support shorter seasons.

3 Likes

I’m hoping that with only 1 (maybe?) Doctor-lite episode this season, it will seem like it has more room to breathe.

I’m not even sure how Doctor-lite Lucky Day is, though.

10 Likes

I have a feeling Ncuti may be in Lucky Day more than we think? No idea but hey. Hopefully it’s akin to Dot and Bubble if it is Doctor-lite, so it feels like he has a presence throughout even if he’s not actively joining in with the main events.

11 Likes

While watching the opening, I kept thinking This is the hardest Murray Gold has ever Murray Golded

6 Likes

I originally thought Lucky Day was just Ruby and UNIT but I think I’m wrong there.

6 Likes

You know, watching back, I really do like that before we’re told about the whole nine thing, Alan says. ā€œHelp me. Save me, Chandra.ā€ā€¦

8 Likes


Rating so far,hoped it would be more

5 Likes

Also, RTD did promise in DWM 8 episodes a season was just ā€œfor nowā€ so maybe if S3 happens, we shall see!

10 Likes

The more I watch, the more I want a transcript, because there’s more 9th word dialogue in there then they recap…

11 Likes

I guess it all depends on what Disney or Disney’s successor order from them! Fingers crossed. I agree that 10 would be a sweet spot for Who.

10 Likes

10 was definitely perfect and i do miss multiple 2 parters

7 Likes

Watched it, and I feel bad for saying this, but I really didn’t enjoy this one.

I think I am overall in agreement with @Goibniu and @ChrisStokes in a lot of their Points.

While I fully support the Messaging and I really don’t mind if it’s on the Nose, I feel like it was dealt here in a Manner, which sadly left a lot to be desired. I will say I really like the Ending with Berlinda, where she protests being treated as just ā€œOne of his Adventureā€, I thought that Scene was excellent and worked quite well. In general Varada is the big saving Grace of this Episode, I already she was a great Actress from other Shows but seeing her in Who is just a Blast. Berlinda so far shows a lot of Promises, more than Ruby, who is still played wonderfully by Millie but at times felt a bit too at Home. So having Berlinda be much more confronting is great.

However.. I really disliked how she puts them all in Danger when she reactivates the Polish Bot. And I kinda wish this got addressed much more in the Story itself, it just didn’t make much sense at all. And even less Sense made the ā€œCharacterā€ of Manny, who feels like a one-noted Caricature whose Lines are just ā€œUghh I hate you Berlinda!!ā€ for most of the Episode. I did like Sasha more, but she got barely much Time to develop, there are some nice short Moments with 15 reflecting on her Death, but it really didn’t hit me as much as I would have hoped. In general, the Supporting Cast just feels like ā€˜nothing’ Characters, despite that, I realy enjoyed the Moments in their Hideout. Seeing Berlinda use her Knowledge as a Nurse was great. The Moment where 15 shows her that he has 2 Hearts? Great. Really that’s the big Highlight of the Episode, outside the ending and well Varada herself.

Don’t really have much to say about the Teases for the Arc or the Mrs. Flood Part, I must admit I hope she doesn’t break the fourth Wall constantly, after a while it can get a bit tiring. I do hope the Arc and its Tease is handled in a more subtle Way than last Time, where we spend way too much Time on Things that didn’t get a very satisfying Payoff.

The Pacing felt quite off, especially the beginning, feels like it’s rushing us into the Story way too much. I enjoyed the Robots, they are fun for this one Episode, but not a Monster I can see or would want to see return. The directing was solid, not outstanding, just kinda okay. Not a big Fan of the Amount of Flashbacks, they felt a bit too crowded here and a few less of them would have been much better.

I do hate to be a Downer, and I am genuinely happy for everybody who had a great Time, there were Things I really enjoyed, but for me this Opener is not doing it. Hopeful for the next Episode regardless, bring it on, Lux :crossed_fingers:

15 Likes