Elimination Game - Male companions

[8] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[3] Ben Jackson
[9] Jamie McCrimmon
[8] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[1] Captain Mike Yates
[7] Harry Sullivan
[7] Vislor Turlough
[4] Wilfred Mott
[8] Rory Williams
Rory is a good man, and good men are hard to find. (Stop taking him for granted, Amy!) Ben has all the distinctiveness of an unsalted cracker.

13 Likes

[8] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[3] Ben Jackson
[9] Jamie McCrimmon
[6] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[2] Captain Mike Yates
[7] Harry Sullivan
[7] Vislor Turlough
[4] Wilfred Mott
[8] Rory Williams

8 Likes

[8] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[3] Ben Jackson
[9] Jamie McCrimmon
[4] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[2] Captain Mike Yates
[7] Harry Sullivan
[7] Vislor Turlough
[4] Wilfred Mott
[9] Rory Williams

I, too, think The Brigadier is a bit overrated and I don’t see how he can be reconciled with The Doctor’s dislike of guns. His most famous quote is about shooting 5 rounds into someone!

Rory is brilliant!

11 Likes

[8] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[3] Ben Jackson
[9] Jamie McCrimmon
[4] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[2] Captain Mike Yates
[7] Harry Sullivan
[5] Vislor Turlough
[4] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

Vislor is the last one on the list that I don’t like.

9 Likes

[8] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[1] Ben Jackson
[10] Jamie McCrimmon
[4] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[2] Captain Mike Yates
[7] Harry Sullivan
[5] Vislor Turlough
[4] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

6 Likes

[9] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[1] Ben Jackson
[10] Jamie McCrimmon
[4] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[2] Captain Mike Yates
[7] Harry Sullivan
[5] Vislor Turlough
[2] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

6 Likes

[9] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[1] Ben Jackson
[10] Jamie McCrimmon
[5] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[7] Harry Sullivan
[5] Vislor Turlough
[2] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

Yeeted Yates.

14 Likes

[9] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[1] Ben Jackson
[10] Jamie McCrimmon
[5] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[5] Harry Sullivan
[6] Vislor Turlough
[2] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

Turlough’s arc is honestly one of if not the strongest in classic who (TV wise) and also it’s just fun to watch him fail miserably at killing the doctor lol. The black guardian really chose the absolutely most pathetic little meow meow to do his bidding and failed spectacularly at it

11 Likes

[9] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[10] Jamie McCrimmon
[5] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[5] Harry Sullivan
[6] Vislor Turlough
[3] Wilfred Mott :arrow_up:
[10] Rory Williams

[-1] Ben Jackson - I don’t dislike Ben, but from what little I’ve seen of him he easily has the least personality here.

I’m fighting on the front lines for Wilf because even if most of the time he’s not a traditional companion, imo he DOES take that role in End of Time. Also I like him :slight_smile:

11 Likes

[9] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[10] Jamie McCrimmon
[5] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[5] Harry Sullivan
[7] Vislor Turlough :arrow_up:
[1] Wilfred Mott :arrow_down:
[10] Rory Williams

Some wild decisions being made in this thread tbh.

7 Likes

[9] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[10] Jamie McCrimmon
[6] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[5] Harry Sullivan
[5] Vislor Turlough
[1] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

5 Likes

[9] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[10] Jamie McCrimmon
[7] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart :arrow_up:
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[5] Harry Sullivan
[3] Vislor Turlough :arrow_down:
[1] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

8 Likes

[9] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[10] Jamie McCrimmon
[7] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[5] Harry Sullivan
[1] Vislor Turlough :arrow_down::arrow_down:
[2] Wilfred Mott :arrow_up:
[10] Rory Williams

I can’t stand losing Wilf again, so I have to try amd save him. Please help me!

13 Likes

[9] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[10] Jamie McCrimmon
[7] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[5] Sergeant John Benton
[5] Harry Sullivan
[3] Wilfred Mott :arrow_up: :saluting_face:
[10] Rory Williams

Cannot vote against Wilf. Let the old soldier keep on fighting!

[-1] Vislor Turlough :arrow_down: :feather: Perhaps siding with the Black Guardian wasn’t such a good idea?

13 Likes

[9] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[11] Jamie McCrimmon
[7] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[3] Sergeant John Benton
[5] Harry Sullivan
[3] Wilfred Mot
[10] Rory Williams

Benton is charming as all hell, but doesn’t feel on the level of these other companions.

7 Likes

[10] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[11] Jamie McCrimmon
[7] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[3] Sergeant John Benton
[5] Harry Sullivan
[1] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

We lost Turlough (a real companion) before Wilf (not a real companion)!!!

9 Likes

[10] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[11] Jamie McCrimmon
[7] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[1] Sergeant John Benton
[6] Harry Sullivan

[1] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

Wilf was a companion imo - End of Time he IS the companion there. No doubt in my mind. Buuuuuut, I’ve got others I need to vote for.

Because no way in my mind is Benton a companion.

11 Likes

[10] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[11] Jamie McCrimmon
[7] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[6] Harry Sullivan
[2] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

[-1] Sergeant John Benton
Sorry, but there is no way I’m letting Wilf be voted out before Benton

10 Likes

[10] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[11] Jamie McCrimmon
[8] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[4] Harry Sullivan
[2] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

These are all great but Harry didn’t get enough time in the TARDIS

7 Likes

[10] Ian Chesterton
[7] Steven Taylor
[11] Jamie McCrimmon
[9] Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart
[2] Harry Sullivan
[2] Wilfred Mott
[10] Rory Williams

Harry Sullivan may not be an imbecile, but he is a little bit of an afterthought in his stories.

7 Likes