Doctor Who - Season 2 (2025)


At the moment, these last few years haven’t been my favourite :sob:

9 Likes

Can someone be a mensch and link me the tiermaker so I don’t have to go scrolling <3

3 Likes

https://tiermaker.com/create/doctor-who-rtd2-episodes-64220

4 Likes

Mostly gut instinct and only watched each of these once (with the exception of Wish World because of the cinema).

7 Likes

You rock thespian, thanks!

The Reality War could still move up, and I wish there was a lower tier shaped like a dustbin that I could throw Lucky Day into.

6 Likes


This is mine. I base my ratings of an episode mostly on how I feel while watching so I tried to put that into the description of the tiers

8 Likes

Sorry to hear that. The good thing is that the present TV era is not all. I did not click with 12 and 13 that much, but after that came an era that was more for me. Maybe the next one will work better for you.

7 Likes

One thing (for me at least) that’s good about what may be an extended hiatus is that I finally have a decent block of time to work on The Book About The Whole Bloody Thing without having to pause and graft a new era into my analysis.

5 Likes

Are you writing or reading this?

3 Likes

Writing! Combination of reviews and essays, heavily influenced by About Time, Running Through Corridors, Eruditorum et al.

Gonna sneak it under the wire and try and be the first one to do a Jodie Whittaker redemption before anyone else gets there.

11 Likes

Thank you :smiling_face: I love how wide ranging Doctor Who is, there is always something for everyone, and I I’m so glad that this era was loved by many, it means that hopefully the show will continue, because i Would hate for it to stop!

8 Likes

Coming back having finished The Reality War, and here are my final TARDIS guide rankings for Season 2:

11 Likes

Looks like you enjoyed most if the season then :grinning_face:

5 Likes

Season 2 is I think, avenues better than Season 1, and definitely better than the specials. But it’s got some really gaping flaws in it. I’m trying my best to see past that as much as possible because I am still a fan of the show, but it’s certainly a strange spot to be in.

7 Likes


Here’s mine out of 5 instead of the better system of 8.

Overall loved the series but The Reality War really really really drags it down for me

7 Likes


feel like pure shit just want them back x

10 Likes

Remember when this scene was the most controversial thing all season :smiling_face_with_tear:

17 Likes

Remember single tears like this stirring up conversation… The simple days… Gone. /hj

7 Likes

And say that their favourite adventure is Scherzo or Seeing I or something :smiling_face_with_tear:

6 Likes

Anyone fancy a game of ‘accidental pin or deliberate pin’?

10 Likes