Audio Writers - Should They Write for the TV Show (Big Finish Main/Monthly Range)

Tucker: I’m not overly impressed with anything that he’s written, but more diversity on TV would still be nice

Pegg: The Spectre of Lanyon Moor is brilliant, so if he did anything like that for TV it would be brilliant.

Cartmel: I really like Winter for the Adept, and I think given his time as script editor he deserves a shot at writing for TV. His stories can be weird as well, which is always nice to see.

9 Likes

Don’t forget Robert Shearman, the man who is eternally doomed to constantly write and rewrite and adapt Jubilee

14 Likes

Tucker and Pegg I don’t really have strong opinions about.

Cartmel could be interesting. I’m not a fan of Winter for the Adept, but he’s a man of strong ideas!

5 Likes

Based on the lost Season 27 audios from BF, I’m not keen on Cartmel writing anything for the TV show…

6 Likes

Ahhhhhh how could I leave out Robert Shearman aka Mr. Literally Never Misses Ever. That man needs and deserves to make a come back in TV.

9 Likes

He pulled out of s5 because Who was too high profile for him, I doubt he’d come back now

12 Likes

It’s wild to me that Goss hasn’t gotten to written for the show when he’s written so much more EU than like anyone else ever :sweat_smile:

I’d love to see a Dorney script on TV, especially if he’s allowed to be as experimental as he is on audio

15 Likes

Such a shame cause him returning is my biggest want!

5 Likes

I was waiting for the next three because he’d have to be in that

It’s genuinely just insane to me he hasn’t, especially when he’s seemingly so close and trusted by the people running the show (to the point where he was able to get a Mavity reference in a story before WBY released)

10 Likes

Yeah I kinda skimmed the thread beforehand and missed that it was in rounds whoops lol

4 Likes

I think it’s alright, people have also just been bringing up names as well!

7 Likes

I’ve just been going through the Monthly Adventures three authors at a time. Other people have brought up other names too and that’s fine.

9 Likes

Whew that’s a relief! Was worried I’d be forced to regenerate…

6 Likes

Ahhhh, that makes sense

Was wondering how you were picking authors!

5 Likes

Here’s the next batch from the Main Range/Monthly Adventures:

Steve Lyons: An author who has written several Doctor Who across several ranges, several short stories, and several DWA comics (mostly for the Eleventh Doctor). He’s also written several audio stories including The Ratings War, Blood of the Daleks, and Gallifrey: Insurgency (2.4). For the Main Range he wrote #12, 25, 80, 99, 132, 244, 255, and 266a. He has not written for the TV show. Should Lyons be commissioned to write an episode of the TV series?

Paul Cornell: Paul Cornell is one that doesn’t really need any introduction, but I’ll give one anyway. Coming on to the scene with the VNAs, Paul Cornell is the creator of Bernice Summerfield. He has also written several short stories and comic stories. For the Main Range he wrote The Shadow of the Scourge (MR #13) and The 100 Days of the Doctor (MR #100d), and co-wrote Seasons of Fear (MR #30) and Circular Time (MR #91). For the TV show, he wrote Father’s Day and Human Nature/The Family of Blood. He has since retired from writing any pre-existing characters (with a couple exceptions). Should Cornell be enticed back to the TV series?

Robert Shearman: Rob Shearman also doesn’t really need any introduction. He’s known for dark comedy that strandles the line between funny and uncomfortable. His Main Range contributions are legendary: The Holy Terror (MR #14), The Chimes of Midnight (MR #29), Jubilee (MR #40), Scherzo (MR #52), and My Own Private Wolfgang (MR #100b)[1]. His one TV script, Dalek is superb. Should Shearman be enticed back to the TV series?


  1. okay maybe this one isn’t legendary, but the rest are ↩︎

9 Likes

YES. YES HE SHOULD. please. If Paul Cornell came back I would literally forgive any fault that hypothetical season may have. All other episodes could be rebroadcasts of Kill the Moon and I wouldn’t care[1].


  1. okay maybe i would but ↩︎

10 Likes

Absolutely yes to all three of those. They’ve written some of Who’s finest stories.

11 Likes

Lyons, why not? Cornell and Shearman, definitely! And bring Benny to TV as well!

6 Likes

Paul Cornell please put Benny on my TV i’m on my hands and knees

10 Likes

Paul Magrs come to TV, I’d love a 15/Iris story

13 Likes