This is a Perfect Example of an Audio that I should really like all Things considered, but it somehow doesn’t connect with me all that much. Wrote a Review to discuss it further here:
When I started listening to this, I thought, “Oh yeah, Colin and Davros together again; that must be good!” And while the scenes they share are definitely great, the story as a whole is just fine. I wasn’t bored but not entirely engaged either. It has good surface-level themes that it never explores more in-depth. And the Mechanoids are utterly wasted.
6/10
The Juggernauts has all the ingredients for a tense, dramatic, and morally complex Dalek tale: a shady Davros, a divided Doctor/companion team, and a twisted new take on the Mechanoids. But it never quite cooks. The pacing is sluggish, the stakes never feel high, and most of the interesting ideas – Davros hiding in plain sight, Mel unknowingly aiding evil, the ethical cost of programming machines to kill – are skimmed over rather than explored in full. It’s a functional, competently made audio, but with Big Finish’s high bar for Dalek stories this one feels like a missed opportunity.
You’re welcome to read my full review below (spoiler alert!):