Iconic tbh I’ll have to like keep it in mind when I’m doing them find my finales and openers
1 Like
Okay this is the first time this series of books I’ve had to STOP myself reading cause I lost track of the time and it’s 3:30am
The book beltempest I kid you not im half way through rn but if it sticks the landing might be my fav EDA so far no even joking what worries me is last time I felt this way about a book the average was low I haven’t unspoiler tagged the average yet gonna wait till I rate it like usual so I swear to god if it’s below 3/5 we are gonna have words again doctor who fans
7 Likes
If it helps, I also really like this one
3 Likes
You will not face my wrath you will be spared if the events happen about 2/3s of the way through rn
2 Likes
I liked Beltempest… 
I think I gave it a 9/10. It’s SO FULL of ideas and such a wild ride. I even drew some watercolours of scenes I found particularly striking! Might dig those out some time…
4 Likes
Okay guys don’t worry as the objectively always correct person on Tardis Guide who has never been wrong in his life I will take it upon myself to read Beltempest and conclude definitively (for all I say is definitive) whether or not Beltempest is a good Doctor Who book
5 Likes
I didn’t hate Beltempest, I was just confused the whole time in a not fun way
2 Likes
I would LOVE to see those
3 Likes
It’s what we deserve
2 Likes
About a 1/3 through the face eaters atm
Ngl I think doing the vnas and edas this year feels so 4D while we wait for the tender to finish I’m not gonna lie
Enjoying face eater so far :)
1 Like
Man I really need to make progress in the VNAs. Been stuck on Venusian Lullaby for 2 months now. It’s not even bad, I just never have motivation for it and struggle to read more than a chapter at a time. But I want to hit these EDAs and judge how good/bad they are too!
3 Likes
EDA s1 ranking
Vampire science 10/10
longest day 10/10
alien bodies 10/10
Eight doctors 9/10
bodysnatchers 8/10
genocide 8/10
kursaal 7/10
war of the daleks 6/10
option lock 5/10
average: 8/10
EDA s2 ranking
Seeing I 10/10
beltempest 10/10
scarlet empress 10/10
Dreamstone moon 10/10
placebo effect 7/10
face eater 7/10
Legacy of the daleks 4/10
janus conjunction 4/10
vanderdekens children 3/10
average: 7/10
3 Likes
Gonna start the taint later a little break now
3 Likes
Not knowing this was fitz introduction changed my life he is the husband I never had
4 Likes
Fitz is underrated!
1 Like
He’s very good so far I do feel Sam has been sidelined unfortunately so the writers can really establish ftiz
But yeah s3 of the edas is very consistent so far lots of good stuff I’ve been told now to do the infinity doctors then I have unnatural history orman and Blum eyeing me up
4 Likes
I’m at the introduction of Faction Paradox in Alien Bodies and I am enthralled so far. This book is great so far. My only real nitpick is given how we see them at first from the Doctor’s pov I kind of wish this book was both an introduction to us the readers and him the character rather than him already knowing about them. I think that’d been more interesting. But again it’s only a nitpick, I’m really enjoying this. Far and above better than most of the other books in this range so far.
6 Likes
I forgot to mention when I was reading Timewyrm: Genesys and Peel was describing the city spaceship buried in the earth I couldn’t help but think “someone watched Robotech” but I quite enjoyed that bit. Lol
1 Like
I have finished unnatural history
I WASNT READY
8 Likes