Whodle 2024-12-16

In one, @deltaandthebannermen is that your IMDB? /lh /j

11 Likes

Nah - my review of it is much more erudite.

10 Likes

In one, twice in a row A generally disliked christmas special as the first review described immediately brought it to mind aha

7 Likes

I do appreciate the feedback and I generally agree with you too. We thought this could work as a fun one for advent, but we wouldn’t do something like this on a regular basis. I do agree that clues should ideally objectively point to a unique episode not just subjectively, and as already pointed out the “happy (tears)” was supposed to clue towards the correct episode but even then there is some room for interpretation. But this was the point of experimenting, trying to see what works, what doesn’t, and most importantly what people enjoy! This forum has been quite useful to hear people’s opinions.

10 Likes

Glad we can be helpful!!

9 Likes

And my criticism was of course intended as constructive and as feedback. Keep up the good work with these.

8 Likes

Got it in 5 Went through most of the Moffat Christmas specials. Misread fairy tale as fantasy so my mind jumped to CORR

7 Likes

In two twoday.

7 Likes

This topic was automatically closed after 2 days. New replies are no longer allowed.