The Tier List Thread

I’ve even gone and sorted them inside the tiers themselves, so the top of “I like it” is probably closer in score to the bottom of “I really like it” than its own bottom. I hope that made sense…

7 Likes

Project Twilight being its own tier named after itself is so funny I love it 20/10

5 Likes

It’s a most deserving, self describing tier. Very efficient.

5 Likes

OwenI know someone who knows Cavan Scott…

5 Likes

There is now

https://tiermaker.com/create/big-finish-short-trips-16926058

5 Likes

Thank you @Speechless!

7 Likes


Torchwood Monthlies i’ve done

7 Likes

The BF Main Range stories I’ve listened to! Predominantly featuring the Eighth Doctor but a couple of others have made it in here

8 Likes

Wet Walls being in the “I hate it” category lol. It was a very…unique story. For some reason I gave it four stars :thinking:.

5 Likes

It’s one of the most disgusting things I’ve ever listened to, I don’t know what on earth they were thinking with all the Gretchen stuff

3 Likes

My MR rankings. Everything up to 35, more of 8, and some assorted 5 stuff.

7 Likes

It was pretty gross, honestly. And by the Gretchen stuff, you mean the twist at the end, right? If so, yeah, that could have been omitted. I don’t know what the point of that was.

2 Likes

Made me give it half a star because you can’t rate things 0/5

2 Likes


Short Trips time!

I couldn’t find it but Lepidoptery for Beginners is also A tier.

8 Likes

Book ratings also! Mostly - but not completely - the EDAs I’ve read so far


7 Likes

I left out the adaptations because I tend to limit myself to only 100% original releases (I decided this when trying to work out which Benny stories to include on that tier list)

5 Likes

Colin’s “The Wings of a Butterfly” is an adaptation :blush:. Originally published in a charity anthology.

3 Likes

Was thinking about listening to the first season of The Lost Stories at some point soon, so I made another tier list:

https://tiermaker.com/create/big-finish-the-lost-stories-16926058

2 Likes

I’ve surprisingly listened to so few of these!

6 Likes

Sontarans is only two stars for the beginning scene. Power and Guardians is me being generous. Macros could probably be five stars.

4 Likes