General Discussion for Ranking Game

General / off topic Forum Games
, ,
323

That would add:

  1. The Night of the Doctor
  2. Forest of the Dead
  3. Remembrance of the Daleks
  4. Silence in the Library
  5. The War Games

Or if you want top 20 of the main show:

  1. Heaven Sent
  2. Midnight
  3. World Enough and Time
  4. The Doctor Falls
  5. City of Death
  6. Blink
  7. The Doctor Dances
  8. The Empty Child
  9. Dalek
  10. Turn Left
  11. The Night of the Doctor
  12. Forest of the Dead
  13. Remembrance of the Daleks
  14. Silence in the Library
  15. The War Games
  16. The Parting of the Ways
  17. Vincent and the Doctor
  18. The Waters of Mars
  19. Genesis of the Daleks
  20. Utopia
10 Likes
324

I feel like all of the top non-DWTV stories are high profile enough that most people who frequent this forum would be familiar with them. And I think it would be a shame to exclude The Chimes of Midnight, A Death in the Family, and CoE Day Five from contention given their reputations.

11 Likes
325

Letā€™s put it to a vote:

  • Top 15 TV stories
  • Top 15 stories
  • Top 20 TV stories
  • Top 20 stories
0 voters
5 Likes
326

I voted TV stories because thereā€™s a handful of stories on audio I still havenā€™t heard and that would make me want to not vote for/against them.

13 Likes
327

I think it would be fun to add audios but I think these games are better when theyā€™re a little.more inclusive, hence TV only

12 Likes
328

When we say TV, are we including the Torchwoods? Because Iā€™d say that CoE is quite well known.
(Please note, anytime Iā€™m talking about anything being well known, you should picture this image)

average_familiarity_2x
average_familiarity_2x589Ɨ961 57.9 KB

12 Likes
329

Iā€™d say K9 is pretty well knownā€¦

15 Likes
330

K9 isnā€™t even close to getting in the top 100 thoughā€¦

15 Likes
331

K9 is second nature to us K9 fans, so itā€™s easy to forget that the average person probably only knows the plot of The Bounty Hunter and Regeneration.

And The Fall of the House of Gryffen, of Course

Of course

15 Likes
332

Interesting. Personally I liked Elimination Games like the Silurian one that (I think) @deltaandthebannermen put together, even if there were MANY stories I was unfamiliar with at first. I read/listened/watched so many Silurian stories over the course of that game because of that.

That being said, I voted Top 20 TV because I think comparing the episodes exclusively is more interesting.

15 Likes
333

Well, itā€™s pretty clear TV is winning but apparently I didnā€™t phrase it well enough, so second vote:

  • Doctor Who only
  • Include Torchwood
0 voters
9 Likes
334

This is the most democratic process before an elimination game! I like it!

15 Likes
335

Well, weā€™re all playing, might as well make sure the most people have the most fun.

15 Likes
336

I think maybe Torchwood could be its own game. Itā€™s very different from the main show.

14 Likes
337

Yeah, and I also donā€™t love having multiple Children of the Earth episodes going up against some of Whoā€™s finest. They feel like very different beasts.

9 Likes
338

The results are in, so I went ahead and made the game. if one of the mods could turn on slow mode, that would be great.

12 Likes
339

Our first flub of the game :joy: We both posted at the same time!

12 Likes
340

And now my vote is off.

10 Likes
341

shhhh I managed to get in there and edit, nobody ever has to know :laughing:

10 Likes
342

You can still fix it!

5 Likes