General Discussion for Elimination/Ranking Game

The Snowmen is also my lowest of what remains, at a 6/10 from me (the last episode below a 7/10!)

4 Likes

This exists as a separate entity from the Assassin’s Creed game:

2 Likes

Only two left lie outside my top 100 of TV Who. (I know some parts here are already gone)
Child/Dances (7)
Blink (22)
Library/Forest (26)
Eleventh (39)
Angels/Stone (44)
Opens/Bang (28)
Carol (29)
Day (5)
Breath (101)
Magician/Witch (86)
Sent (1)
Husbands (64)
Pilot (106)
Extremis (73)
World/Falls (2)

5 Likes

Oof, I love The Pilot and Extremis!

Lovely stats.

6 Likes

To be fair. They’re both still 8/10.

3 Likes

simpsons-mad

8 Likes

I love watching @eevee absolutely commit to her bit

8 Likes

We need a conflicted emoji. In this case, I like the upvote but dislike the downvote. Don’t know how it would look…

10 Likes

JayPea, do your thing. Laid it up for you.

8 Likes

:rainbow::rainbow_flag::partying_face::man_dancing: :tardis: :tardispink: :k9:

7 Likes

In my defense the only episodes left I think are not a 10/10 besides Day is The Eleventh Hour and The Husbands of River Song and it has been a looooooong time since Day would have been my target anyway.

I already held on for people who like it, now it’s fair game!

7 Likes

Eleventh Hour and Day are two of my most beloved episodes :sob::sob::sob::sob::sob:

5 Likes

With my post the other day, the one I’d pick to down becomes obvious.

2 Likes

I was too late!!!

3 Likes

Uhh, something has gone wrong.

2 Likes

@koquillicsoothsayer I think you didn’t scroll all the way down when you played the elimination game, so your vote doesn’t make sense. You want to copy the last post in the thread (double check). To vote, subtract 2 from least favorite,add 1 to favorite. We’re still happy you want to play with us, though! :grinning:

3 Likes

Yeah. The last post was quoting one from ages ago because Husbands and Carol were still in the list.

I’ve deleted the post and messaged @koquillicsoothsayer .

4 Likes

Both parts of The Empty Child and Silence in the Library still being the game is quite fun. I imagine the vote is being split a little…

For me personally the ending of The Doctor Dances– which is so joyful and perfect– overshadows the The Empty Child just a little, so I’m likely to vote for the second episode. Both parts of the Library story are pretty equal in my mind.

Anyone else have any thoughts? :eyes:

8 Likes

Yeah, it’s lovely seeing a Two Parter survive for so long with both of his entries, let alone two!
Sadly, I feel like Forrest of the Dead will be out soon. Although I agree, it’s pretty much the same Quality wise between those two. I am not sure which I prefer, I do think The Empty Child is sightly better for me, but then again The Doctor Dances is great and has one of the best Endings of any Revival Episode.
“Just this once, Rose, everybody lives!”

9 Likes

I’ve personally been tending to vote for whichever of the two is behind at the time…

6 Likes