General Discussion for Elimination/Ranking Game

Love the games (even if no one seems to understand what the correct opinions to have are /j ) but what would be cool would be if we could maybe have a bit more downtime between people’s games.

They seem to be popping up quite regularly and no sooner has one ended that another one starts.

It would be great if some space was given for some different people to have the chance to run some.

11 Likes

I’d disagree here, as not everyone will participate in every game.

There’s some I’m not interested in (because I don’t know the topic that well: like best villains in old Doctor Who stories I’ve never seen)

But then there’s always others going on that do interest me.

Just my two cents, not sure if anyone thinks the same.

7 Likes

And it’s not like it’s the same person running each one. We’ve got four running at the moment (Sarah Jane, One-Time Villain, Twelfth Doctor, Main Range 1-64) and each one is being run by a different person. There’s nothing to say someone can’t start another one tomorrow.

7 Likes

That’s fine but I do think maybe some people feel they can’t start a new one if there are so many already running and there’s not much time in between to jump in and start a new one. It’s all about optics. Not saying anyone should stop, just trying to bring a bit of awareness to how it might be looking.

9 Likes

Fair enough. It just felt like the way you phrased it…

…seemed to imply that one or two people had monopolized on these.

1 Like

These four are, yes. And before these there were earlier games, and they were run by mostly the same users. The current situation is more of an exception. Also, four games simultaneously is a bit much. I know we’ve talked about this before, when we got very excited about those games and we had so many running that people lost interest a bit.

8 Likes

Sorry I wasn’t aware of any of this.

I just see them as silly fun, something to do whilst on here.

I don’t keep track of who runs them, or anything like that.

6 Likes

I’ve thought about running a gallifrey tournament a few times but never seemed to have the motivation the exact moment there was a lull in them happening. To be fair, i think part of it is also just that these will logically run for quite a long time with how many items there are so that may increase the felt number of them

8 Likes

Maybe hold off until July, and then run it after we’ve had the chance to listen to War Room 3.

He’s pointing one of his fingers at me :innocent:. But I learned and I’m running fewer games these days. In fact, it’s down right nice to not be running one! :grinning_face: I only ran the latest elimination game so soon after my previous game because there seemed to be a lot of sentiment for one. I have a longish list of game ideas and new ones regularly pop into my mind[1]. In any event, I’m giving it a break, maybe a loooong one, as I’m looking forward to the one-time villain mega-tournament and the new BF 1-64 Main Range tournament[2]. And I’m quite intrigued by @Blossom’s idea of an elimination game with twists.

And now that I’ve been properly chasitised by the great @deltaandthebannermen I’ll go off to my room to sulk in private :wink:.


  1. stupid, stupid brain :astonished_face: ↩︎

  2. if my stupid, stupid brain can remember anything about the stories ↩︎

12 Likes

Not pointing fingers or chastising anyone. Just airing some thoughts.

6 Likes

Who stole your sense of humour? :laughing:

6 Likes

Full disclosure, I have no idea what an elimination game is but this looked like fun. I missed it, didn’t I? That or I have no idea what is going on.

2 Likes

It got eliminated in yet another game…

5 Likes

Btw I was immediately[1] going to jump from 3rd doctor to whichever was next I think six(?) but if more of a gap between each of these one time villain per doctor of the community I don’t have to be as eager to run the next one lol


  1. like a week or so ↩︎

3 Likes

One about stories with “World” or “Planet” in the title ended yesterday.

5 Likes

Pretty much there is a list of characters, stories, etc., and they all start with the same number of points and you give 1 point to an entry and remove 2 pts from one you want to eliminate. Once it hits 0 (or -1) it’s eliminated. And you can typically post once every 20 hrs so it is a bit of strategy on your part keeping what you want in or eliminating stuff

5 Likes

You can find all of them under elimination-game (we’ve had 52 games since the start of the forum!).

4 Likes

Once a few have ended I might do it! It may surprise people to know it’s a tv one :sweat_smile:

4 Likes

Just to check, when’s a safe bet to start a new one roughly? Looking at the plan I made last year it would last 11 days for mine.

3 Likes