Its not… Interstellar is. It is OK for you to love something and others to not, we’ve been having this discussion elsewhere tonight. For me, I felt that for a finale, you shouldn’t leave all the reveals and main elements to part 2, and have them instead be spread across both. I didn’t like how long it took the Doctor to wake up, I didn’t enjoy seeing Carla kicking Ruby out yet again.
9 Likes
and now we have the finale which will likely go under 3 stars
2 Likes
I really enjoyed Wish World 
was it a bit of a mess? Maybe. But I had soo so much fun so it rated well by me
16 Likes
Ever the optimist… I see you’re just ignoring the fact what you said was untrue about how they rated
8 Likes
Same here. I was pretty surprised to read this thread and see that other people didn’t love it, although i understand why
9 Likes
Yeah, I really loved it. Like my absolutely most important metric is always whether or not I had fun and I had so much fun watching it, so it’s good for me.
10 Likes
I enjoyed it, but spent the entire runtime trying to figure out the Rani’s plan. For me, it’s upper-mid (around a 3.5 I think), but I’m kinda waiting to see what they do in Part 2 for me to really understand my feelings on it.
7 Likes
I haven’t posted ratings for anything beyond Hartnell’s first season, but if it makes you feel any better, I’d rate the majority of this new season very highly (9s and 10s for nearly all of them). 
7 Likes
I think it depends how part 2 goes, but I really do feel like too much has been left for it. Should’ve had more in part 1. Same issue with last year really, Legend was purely set up for Empire.
5 Likes
Well. I gave it three.
But I wouldn’t get too caught up in ratings. There’s plenty of stories I’ve rated high that others dislike. Star ratings are a bit of an inexact science tbh.
10 Likes
Hoping we get an on-set performance for Omega rather than CG+Voice acting,
I wonder if we might get a little bit of stunt casting like Dalton as Rassilon.
11 Likes
Well, of the actors who have played him, maybe we could get either Peter Davison or Brian Blessed?
10 Likes
Brian Blessed PLEASE yes
7 Likes
I’d love Omega to actually be there but tbh from what we’ve seen I reckon he’s gonna be a bit like Galactus in the original F4 movies - a disembodied CGI storm of some kind. Which would kinda make sense considering his whole schtick is that he’s made of nothing but willpower in the anti matter universe
9 Likes
I’ve never written a review for a ‘new’ episode before, but I wanted to give it a go.
10 Likes
Great review!
7 Likes
Blessed would be a blessing. CGI cloud would be a disappointment
9 Likes
Hell even just the original appearance of the outfit and mask with just a voice would be sick
9 Likes
Just wanted to pop in here away from the crazy reactions to The Reality War and say I came across a video (I think on Instagram) from a wheelchair user praising the representation of disabilities in Wish World. I thought it was interesting to see that point of view bearing in mind how some people were quite critical of the way that part of the cast were depicted/involved. Always good to be reminded that there is always a spectrum of opinion on any issue and neither side is necessarily right or wrong.
17 Likes
Here’s the video:
10 Likes