Doctor Who Would You Rather?

Everyone needs to vote for Eleven and Rory audios or I’m quitting the forum forever!

12 Likes

You just made me change my vote from Matt to Peter!

10 Likes

I shouldn’t be trusted with either the show or any audios, i wouldn’t make something most people enjoy lol

6 Likes

Neither did Bill Strutton, but that didn’t stop him!

5 Likes
  1. Peter and Jenna join Big Finish. Even though I would love to have them together, having them join Big Finish would be great since there’s lots of stuff they could explore.
  2. Create an audio range. I like both but audio sounds more my thing for this. I have more room to express myself and I don’t have to worry about visuals.
  3. Nothing of that happens
  4. Timeline messed by the Trickster. I don’t think I would survive that long in the past.
8 Likes

Trickster for sure. In all likelihood I wouldn’t know the difference. Being stuck in the past… well it depends how far back, but I can’t imagine it would go well. Ignoring the whole brown and trans thing, I’m disabled, of the currently a medical mystery sort. It’s unlikely I’d have a very good quality of life. Assuming I don’t die immediately of spanish flu or something, that is.

9 Likes

New Who, because that means everything made from 2005-onwards, which is the bulk of the franchise at this point.

TV only. It hurts to abandon the audios, but the main show is just too special to me to give it up. I need to be in the right mood for the audios, but I’ll watch the show any old time.

Clara only works with Twelfth IMO, so the chance of her character being with anyone else doesn’t sound good to me. I’d rather have Eleventh and Rory as a duo, as there’s potential for interesting character beats from them both without Amy there. (feel free to read into that statement however you wish)

Writing an entire audio range myself sounds exhausting. Why do that when I could bring in several writers as showrunner (off the top of my head, Jamie Mathieson, Vinay Patel, Marc Platt, John Dorney, Paul Magrs, Paul Cornell, and Mark Gatiss just to amuse myself), and create my own all-star season? I’d be a bit less hands-on than most modern showrunners, probably closer to a classic-era script editor, but that sounds like the more fun option to me.

The missing episodes are such a scarred aspect of the show, it feels like the right thing to do to make sure they are all found again. Even if it means losing the main audios (although, in conjunction with the previous option, I’d make sure BF writers still got to work on the franchise afterwards).

Ugh, reality being mucked up by the Trickster feels like it would drive me mad after a while. Not trying to go full Main Character Syndrome, but I just get the feeling I’d notice that something wasn’t right, even if I wasn’t entirely certain what it was. It’d hurt to leave my loved ones behind in the present, but at least I’d have a chance to tell them that I still lived a good life somewhere else (it says “no way of going back” but I don’t see a clause preventing me sending time-delayed messages). Like with most things, Weeping Angels win this one.

9 Likes

No 12/Clara audios is sad… BUT! Consider the possibilities! Clara and Me’s adventures! More of the 12/Bill/Nardole/Missy team! Imagine!

As for Weeping Angels vs. The Trickster… nothing says the latter situation can’t be fixed by some meddling kids. :wink:

10 Likes

And their robot dog too

9 Likes

Definitely Trickster - both because you probably wouldn’t notice, and because with any luck the Bannerman Road gang would be on the case. If I got sent back in time I’d become a DW villain in my own right as soon as the next migraine came :laughing:

8 Likes

Who do you want as the next conpanion

  • The kid with glasses from the Polar Express that you just want to punch so badly
  • Penfold
0 voters


8 Likes

Never seen Polar Express so I chose Penfold but only if voiced by Terry Scott.

5 Likes

Lucky

5 Likes

I don’t know who Penfold is but that Polar Express child is annoying, so he gets my vote lol

5 Likes

How is this even a question?

6 Likes

Old timers like Delta & myself know

7 Likes

There was this one episode I used to watch over and over on DVD when I was younger, I remember so many details but can’t find out which one it was :sob:

5 Likes

I was going to post an educational video as well.

4 Likes

I like danger mouse, i caught a few eps of the older version

4 Likes

God this is nostalgic, I haven’t seen any of this since I was wee!

6 Likes