Comic Club: D11Y2.2 The One

Lol. I did not know that this was going to happen :joy:

4 Likes

Yep, that story has pretty bad art :eyes: I remember thinking that they’ve completely ruined River!

3 Likes

Just wait until you hit Empire of the Wolf and you won’t complain about this art anymore lol

3 Likes

I have read the whole collection now. This story is just not doing anything for me. The characters are badly written, the threat is just big and abstract, and the art is terrible. I am glad that there is only one book left of Eleven’s second year; it has been the worst part of Titan yet for me.

2 Likes

What’s wrong with Empire of the Wolf?

2 Likes

Putting a few examples under a cut, it’s mostly badly drawn characters

Summary

For example, this is Rose Tyler:
1000019049

And now, which doctor would you say is on the left here?


You probably guessed wrong, because that’s meant to be Paul McGann.
If that image seems familiar though, you’re right because a lot of the art is also traced (which is not necessarily a bad thing if used properly which it very much isn’t here).

Compare for example, this panel


And this promotional photo for the TV movie
1000019048
This same piece of art has also been used in at least four more panels in the rest of the comic, with only very minor alterations.

I don’t know what kind of stress the artist was going through for this, but imo this needed a lot more work

3 Likes

A ashame, as Ingranata’s work on Origins and Missy was really good.

2 Likes

Yeah, her other work is much better from what I remember, so I’d guess it was probably a rush job, and outside pressure, I mean, you never know what precisely is going on behind the scenes. A lot of it really seems like ‘this comic has to be done in two days, where can I cut a corner’

2 Likes

An I thought it was Cpt Jack dressed as Ten :joy:

3 Likes

Just finished this volume and loved it, it’s so deliciously dark and the timey wimey shenanigans are great. My main complaint is River didn’t need to be here and was weirdly assholish, but that’s about it. I love seeing a darker side of the Doctor, the Squire is a fascinating character I’m so invested in, and Daak is great comic relief in addition to being plain old fun. The worldbuilding goes crazy and the slowly unraveling mystery is such a good time. There’s so much to get invested in here and the new characters elevate it lots. Also the war doctor!! I haven’t listened to his BF stuff so I’m so excited to get into War Doctor EU via this comic.

reads the rest of the comments in this forum

… Is this how Whittaker-era fans feel?

6 Likes

Yes.

Yes it is.

4 Likes