Tell me, if you were a showrunner and it was decided that the season were to adapt Big Finish stories, what stories what you have? Would you change them to fit a story arc? Would you make one a regeneration? How long would your season be? Who would the companion be? Tell me everything!
And if you want you can even have a classic season and modern season or a mix of both, go crazy, I want to see Cuddlesome as a season finale!
The whole Hex Arc would be great for the small screen, but you’d probably have to change it to exclude Project: Twilight and Project: Lazarus because having two random stories set before the rest of the season with a different Doctor, companion and story arc just really wouldn’t work.
I’d also love to have Zagreus on screen, but it’s so lore heavy and reliant on prior who knowledge it’d probably whittle the fandom down to roughly the members of this forum
I would finally put Eight back on our screens. The Charley audios are already an arc spanning three season. Easy era. Yeah, Scherzo probably wouldn’t translate great to a visual medium, but I don’t care.
If all else fails, only ever show small parts of one thing for scenes, so if someone’s talking show only THEIR mouth, or if it’s a cutting scene just the flesh separating, have a white gradient around the screen constantly. It would give a very isolated and weird feeling.
Big Finish is vast and my experience is relatively limited, so I’d start with some highlights from the early days.
1. Storm Warning (would work for any kind of companion introduction, really) 2. Whispers of Terror 3. The Fearmonger 4. The Marian Conspiracy 5. The Mutant Phase 6. Colditz 7. The Holy Terror 8. The Sword of Orion 9. The Stones of Venice
And I’d get into some stuff that could be a refined a bit that had a lot of potential:
10. Invaders from Mars 11. Minuet in Hell 12. The Land of the Dead 13. Loups-Garoux
And, for a Christmas Special: The Chimes of Midnight
Like
The Curious Incident of the Doctor in the Night-time
Year of the Pig
River of Death (not Big Finish, but a BBC Audio)
Plight of the Pimpernel
The Artist at the End of Time
…Ish
DW and the Pirates
I wouldn’t put these all in one season, but they’re audios I’d like to see televised with their original cast.
I think with Big Finish a lot of it wouldn’t adapt to TV too well. For example my favourite range the companion chronicles has a lot of great stories that wouldn’t work as well on TV, think the Last Post, Ghost in the Machine, The Scorchies.
So to adapt Big Finish you’d also need to shake the premises up.
So, my idea would be Live 34. We could adapt the premise of a radio station into a TV station. Plus the story whilst generic ‘Doctor topples regime’ is one of my favourites of early Big Finish due to the quirky premise.