It is yeah! I hope they don’t I honestly don’t care for more stories with that character
1 Like
Quick question about this.
I’ve not listened to them yet but @PlumPudding just pointed out that they are on the Guide as a story for each “part”, which isn’t right.
I had a look and I now believe I did this by mistake. They should have one entry per story.
I can fix this, but it will affect people’s stats. Only about 25 people have rated each of them anyway though.
Do we think it’s a good idea to just merge these? @JayPea ?
3 Likes
Personally I disagree with what was said on discord, I’ve always rated them as individual stories because the quality differs between them but if it’s the general consensus then I’m happy to move to that. To me though they’re just like God Among Us or Doom Coalition really!
2 Likes
No other boxsets are merged as one story other than Outbreak and Believe…which imo, should be separated still?
Unless you view it more like with the Classic era?
1 Like
Are they all separate stories that could be listened alone or is it one big story split into parts?
I guess the argument is that it’s more like a Classic era story.
2 Likes
Personally it is one big plotline for all 6 stories in each boxset. There’s no defining Event that separates each story and they kind of lead into one another.
But when it comes to that line of thinking, I’d also put Before The Fall as one story too. And then more generally, it’d be the same for Dark Eyes too, for example. Same with the Redacted series, which I’d say Soho is more like.
(And then my audio stories would drop 
) /hj
1 Like
I suppose though, one big difference would be looking at how BF advertise the Soho sets. For example the recent 3DA Brain Drain is listed as one story made up of 6 parts, whereas Soho is a series consisting of 6 parts.
1 Like
That’s true. Boxsets do equate to series.
Feels so good to say Torchwood One has 5 series 
1 Like
I guess I’ll just leave it, as people can’t agree and the easiest thing is to leave it how it is 
3 Likes
(Yay for my audio count 
) (That audio badge is so prettyy)
2 Likes
This would be the main reason I’d keep it the way it is at the moment, yeah
3 Likes
Did I? I could’ve done a while ago and don’t remember, but if it was on the discord then I’m not on there, there must be a second plum pudding floating around.
3 Likes
Oh no, there is another one, the Plum Pudding on discord is @ThePlumPudding lmao
4 Likes
Plum Pudding for everyone!!
3 Likes
Ah, sorry for the confusion!!
2 Likes
Just wait until I join the discord, that’s when the real confusion will start!
3 Likes
Hello, yes, there is another Plum Pudding. I’m the writer one, if that helps distinguish things. Probably doesn’t. I keep hearing about another Plum Pudding who used to be on Amino. Is that you, or are there three of us?
Anyway yeah I maintain that the Soho sets are one story per set. I know people probably won’t agree, but I think stories like Before the Fall and Dark Eyes are more seperated part to part than Soho. I don’t mind if people disagree though.
5 Likes
Welcome. Fell free to hop over to Introductions and tell us a bit about yourself.
I wasn’t on amino, there is a third plum pudding in the mix.
Edit: I can’t wait until we get to take down Omega.
5 Likes
Coming Soon from Big Finish Productions… The Three Plum Puddings… Volume One…
4 Likes